Wednesday, December 06, 2006

John Turner Was a Dual Citizen, And Nobody Fucked With Him

1) The Right Honourable John Turner was born in Richmond, Surrey, England in 1929 to Leonard Turner and Phyllis Gregory, and emigrated to Canada as a baby in 1932.

2) A child born in the UK to a parent who is a British citizen or 'settled' in the UK is automatically a British citizen by birth.

Therefore,

3) John Turner was a U.K./Canadian Citizen when he served as PM from June 30, 1984 to September 17, 1984.

HE NEVER RENOUNCED HIS U.K. CITIZENSHIP!!! THE HORROR!!! THE HORROR!!! etc.

Except that the Ezra Levants of the time never complained. How come? Is it due to the fact that Turner was English and Dion French? In other words, is this whole mini-scandal "about" nothing other than anti-French bigotry?

Under Dion, Libs at 35% in Quebec

...just behind the Bloc at 37%, with the Tories down to 17% of votes, followed by the hapless NDP at 6%.

Thanks to Paul Wells for this. He translates a Presse canadienne story re. a Leger Marketing poll conducted last weekend.

Wells concludes his blog post thusly:

The Liberals have thus gained 9 points in voter intentions in only a week, whereas every other party has lost ground in the same period.

Unelectable in Quebec, eh? Cough...cough...cough

Water Still Flows on Mars

...NASA announced this morning, showing pictures taken by the Mars Global Surveyor before it fell silent in November.

Actually, I've been waiting for this announcement a couple of days now, and I am a bit disappointed. Evidence (also uncovered by the Global Surveyor) for recent water flows on the Red Planet is a couple of years old. Thus far it has mostly been in the form of gullies in crater walls which appear to have been formed by a liquid cascade of some kind. However, the new pictures also:

...[document] the formation of new craters on the plant's surface and [show] bright, light-coloured deposits in gullies that were not present in previous photos.

They concluded the deposits - possibly mud, salt or frost - were left there when water recently cascaded through the channels.

I think it is one of these deposits visible in the picture top left.

Pat Martin & Big Assed Jack Layton Join the Fringe

Led by right wing mouth breather Ezra Levant, NDP MP Pat Martin and Party leader Jack "Assman" Layton pandered to the lowest form of nativism today by demanding that Lib Leader Stephane Dion give up his French citizenship:

Mr. Martin said it would be "common sense for Dion to renounce his French citizenship."

"Mr. Dion should not have divided loyalties," the Manitoba MP said.

"If he were ever to be the premier leader of Canada, this is going to be a problem for him and he should not be so dismissive of people raising the question," Mr. Martin said.

Jack Layton too joined the madness, saying that:

I would prefer that a leader of a party hold only Canadian citizenship, because one represents many Canadians, and for me that means that it's better to remain the citizen of one country.

What solid reason can anyone give for Dion to renounce his citizenship, other than that this might appease a few Conservative bush monkeys from the foothills past the outskirts of Gooberville? Does anyone seriously believe, as Mr. Martin suggests, that Dion might, as Prime Minister, have to recuse himself from French/Canadian trade negotiations because of his moma was born in France?

And if Pat and Jack really feel Dion's loyalty is to France first, how would a mere renunciation of citizenship change this? The man lived in Paris, for chrissakes, he's eaten snails! His soul may be infected with Frenchiness, and therefore entirely past saving.

What really galls me is the hypocrisy involved here. In Ezzy Levant's original column, he writes:

Imagine the shrieks from the media if the Conservatives were to elect a leader who is a dual citizen of the U.S.

This is actually pretty easy to imagine, as the Alberta Conservatives almost did elect Ted Morton for party leader and Premier. But I personally did not hear anything in the way of shrieking over the matter. There were too many other issues with the guy to worry about trivia.

However, maybe some concern should have been expressed. If Ted really was some kind of Yankee fifth columnist, he could have done immense damage as Alberta Premier. For example, say Dion became PM and levied a 1/2 penny gas tax. Maybe Ted's American Masters would order him to take Alberta out of Confederation, become the 52nd state, build a wall around Alberta, and lob encephalitic downers over the wall at Toronto with some kind of giant catapult?

In fact, though his leadership bid failed, Ted will almost certainly assume a powerful position within the Alberta government. He might still be a danger to the nation. Shouldn't he be required to renounce his dual citizenship, and maybe tear up an American flag on television just for good measure?

Perhaps we should hold a full-blown witch-hunt! According to CTV:

Dozens of MPs were actually born outside of Canada, although they may not necessarily retain their dual citizenship. Among them, Justice Minister Vic Toews was born in Paraguay, Health Minister Tony Clement in England, and New Democrat Olivia Chow in Hong Kong.

They might all betray Canada, unless we--I don't know, how to you renounce your citizenship?--make them do a little dance on TV that ends with their tearing up their foreign passports.

PS. Thumbs down to Liberal MP Paul Szabo, for drinking from the same coolaid container.

Tuesday, December 05, 2006

Garth Spanks Ezra

On his blog today, over the now infamous column accusing Stephane Dion of being disloyal to Canada because he is a dual Canadian/French citizen by birth.

However, Garth's post is in itself more than a little offensive. He writes:

But, but, but, this is an issue that Dion needs to address and clarify. If he thinks he’s got the remotest chance of becoming the Canadian prime minister, then the appropriate thing to do is give up that French wad and stay as a simple colonial. It may be cool on campus to be a citizen of the world, or at least the world’s most self-possessed country, but in cold Ottawa, we stay vanilla.

Personally, I think the correct response to any Conservative demanding that Dion give up his French citizenship is to tell them to blow it out their nose. For, if Dion's loyalty is not in question, and Garth says it is not, then exactly what would such a move "clarify"? And to whom? The likes of Garth? The like of Ezra? Sorry, but in this country the fringe justifies itself before the mainstream, and not vice-versa.

I also think Ezra ought to show a bit of class and apologize in writing. Not that I expect that to happen.

News Flash: Velvet Underground Album Makes Money!

From CTV:

A bidding war has been sparked by an online auction for a rare Velvet Underground acetate album, which a Canadian bought for a mere 75 cents four years ago.

At the time this story was written, bids had surpassed a whopping US $124,000, about a week after the acetate was first posted for sale [on E-Bay].

...which is probably more than the Velvets ever made during their whole seven or eight year existence as a band.

The disc is a preliminary pressing of the infamous first album The Velvet Undergound and Nico (with the banana peel that peels) which, while it ushered in a new Rock era (you can't really imagine Punk without the Velvets), tanked financially, as did all of their subsequent efforts.

The recording features two fewer songs than the 11-track recording that went on the market.

At least four of the songs are completely different versions of classic songs such as "Heroin" and "Venus in Furs."

I only hope this material gets released in some form or another, although the sound quality is said to be (by modern standards at least) "unlistenable".

In an age (late 70s & and early 80s) of big hair and Van Halen, I tried forever to convince people that these guys were Rock Visionaries. None of my friends could stand them. People kept telling me that the singer (Lou Reed) couldn't sing and that the guitars were too noisy and there was too much feed-back. I mean, my god! feedback in Rock n' Roll! The Horror!

The best way I knew to kill a party was put on "Sister Ray" from the black album, or "The Black Angel's Death Song" from VU and Nico, and watch people run screaming for the exits.

PS. if you want to hear something really wild (not necessarily good), download the Zoobombs covering "I'm Waiting For the Man", and bathe in the electric mayhem.

More on Dion as French Double Agent

...I mean "dual citizen". Whoopsie!

As everyone probably knows by now, Stephane Dion is a French/Canadian dual citizen due to the fact that:

Mr. Dion's mother, Denyse, was a real-estate agent. Born in Paris, she gave her children their dual citizenship; Léon Dion would joke he was the only one in the household to be solely Canadian.

Over at the Ezra Levant's Western Standard, they are hashing out the implications. My favorite nutty bit of speculation is that Dion has not spoken re. the Rwandan genocide because he is covering up French involvement.

And then there's your standard issue Bigotry, served straight up:

...it seems that Dion is totally unaware of the optics of being a member of French speaking minority in a predominantly English speaking country holding public office who on one hand pretends to be staunch Canadian federalist and on the other holds citizenship of France.

Of course the fact that Ted Morton, who nearly became leader of the Alberta Conservative party, is a dual Canadian/U.S. citizen gets quickly glossed over.

Johnson wrote that patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel. What does this make people like Ezra and his fans, who are willing to stoop so low as to use it as the first move in their political play book?

Monday, December 04, 2006

Ezra Levant, No Class Act

By now everyone knows (h/t to Ted) that Conservative pundit Ezra Levant has, less than 48 hours after Stephane Dion's selection as Liberal leader, accused Mr. Dion of being more loyal to France than to Canada.

This is so over the line that one must question the wisdom of the Calgary Sun even publishing such nonsense.

But Ezzy's history is littered with incredibly tacky behavior, from suing his fellow Tories more or less at random, to intially refusing to step aside during the 2002, Calgary-Southwest by-election so that newly elected Canadian Alliance leader Stephen Harper could run in a safe seat:

At a news conference in Calgary, Levant said he discussed the issue with Harper on Tuesday.

He said the will of the grassroots process that earned him the nomination has to be respected, and said Harper agrees with him.

"He did not ask me to violate our way of doing business," Levant said.

But other members of the Alliance, including MPs, say Levant should have acted differently.

"One person's self-interest shouldn't override the entire party," said Diane Ablonczy, who also ran for the leadership.

Harper will now have to look for an Alliance MP willing to step aside so he could run in a byelection in their riding.

Of course, after days of public ridicule, Ezzy eventually threw in the towel, and the whole sordid story can be found at The Ambler.

Frankly, I think this deserves an official BigCityLib denunciation. So here we go.

From one angry geek to another, Ezzy,

I DENOUNCE THEE, EZRA LEVANT! OOOOOOH! I SO DENOUNCE THEE!

BBC to Climate Skeptics: Put Up or Shut Up

The Beeb's Richard Black writes that:

Of all the accusations made by the diverse community of climate skeptics, the most damaging by far is that the institutions of science have become biased against research which questions the IPCC consensus [that Global Warming is real and man-made], or which builds alternative explanations for the warming we have seen over the last century or so, and the other physical trends which go along with it.

Here, in the internet prairie, we find comments such as: "Science has become as blatantly biased in the direction of tragedy as television. But, given the way we fund and reward science and scientists, it was inevitable."


We find the IPCC criticized along the lines that it is "...an artfully constructed presentation of just the science that supports the fear of human-induced climate change. It is as one sided as a legal brief, which it resembles."

We find blanket condemnations such as: "We know that one's career and income are closely related to one's position on global warming."

These, aimed at the heart of science, are serious accusations. It is as though the apple tree, rather than the fruits, were rotten.

So the Beeb plans to investigate! In fact, they have issued a challenge to Global Warming Deniers. If you feel that the scientific community is targeting you or other skeptics,

...if you have evidence [documentary proof, not links to websites or vague ramblings] of research grants turned down because of a clash with the prevailing consensus, of instances where journals or conference organizers or consensus bodies have rejected "inconvenient" findings, please send it to us; my email address is at the bottom of this article.

It is also right here: Richard.Black-INTERNET@bbc.co.uk.

So, in light of all this, I hereby summon you, TOM HARRIS, Executive Director of the Natural Resources Stewardship Project (NRSP), to rise of from your dark pit, darken this blog once again with your scratchings and, more importantly, send your proofs to the Beeb.

If you are right, Science must be razed to its very Foundations, and the structure rebuilt from scratch! Best if we get started swiftly!

Hébert Column Refuted Before Ink Dry!

Chantel Hébert's Monday column, For Harper, a double-edged sword , filed at 1:00 am this morning, was falsified less than six hours later by this Strategic Counsel poll. In her column, Chantel retails that whole "Quebec hates Dion" line that seperatists have been peddling for years. In fact, according to Chantel, Dion is unpopular all across this great land:

At least in the short term, the outcome of the weekend's leadership convention diminishes the Liberal capacity to swiftly build a pan-Canadian progressive coalition to defeat Harper.

Outside Quebec, Dion is currently less attractive to New Democrat sympathizers than Bob Rae could be expected to be and in Quebec he is less likely to raise his party from the dead than Michael Ignatieff would have.

The new Liberal leader will need more than the few months that may be left before Canada takes a return trip to the polls to fix the latter.

More than a few months or just a few minutes? A Strategic Counsel poll, reported at 6:30 am in the Globe and Mail seems to suggest that Quebec has already embraced Dion, with 62% of Quebecers (as compared to 55% of Canadians as a whole) calling him a "good choice" for Liberal leader.

Now, of course, all the caveats for polls conducted after a successful convention and a week's positive media coverage are in place, but with respect to the Quebec approval figure, I think Paul Wells puts it best:

...if Dion were radioactive in Quebec, there would be no way to put lipstick on that pig.

There has already been speculation in some quarters (like here) that the political dynamic in Quebec going forward will have less to do with obscure constitutional issues which nobody outside of policy wonks and Star columnists care anything about, and more to do with the fact that the Libs have chosen a native son.

Not that Duceppe and Co. will not challenge Dion at every opportunity on Constitutional issues, but there is no reason to believe that Dion cannot do what Chretien did with immigration or job-training, which is to defuse nationalist sentiment by arranging the devolution of highly specific powers to Quebec and other provinces asking for them.

No Tourist He!

Iggy will keep his seat and run next time! Good on him.

It's going to be weird saying nice stuff about Iggy, or even finding other things to write about. I feel a little bit empty inside.

The Dion Bounce

From The Globe:

MONTREAL — There are early signs that Stéphane Dion and his party emerged from their weekend convention ahead of the governing Conservatives, for the first time since the Liberals' election defeat in January.

[...]

It shows that if an election were held today, the Liberals led by Mr. Dion would garner 37 per cent of the vote, compared with 31 per cent for the Conservatives. The NDP polled 14 per cent, the Bloc Québécois 11 per cent, and the Green Party, 7.

Moreover, the decision to select a a Francophone, even a hardcore Federalist one, has played well in...surprise, surprise...Quebec:

In Quebec, 62 per cent of respondents in the province said Mr. Dion was a good choice for the Liberals, with only 29 per cent saying he was a bad choice. The approval of the Liberals' pick was higher in Quebec than in the rest of the country, where 55 per cent like the choice.

Yes of course the Libs were going to get a bounce if they had selected a headless chicken for leader, and yes of course Dion has a chance to spoil the nation's positive first impressions. However, I would take a good-news meaningless poll over a bad news meaningless poll any day.

And, meanwhile, the Stephen Harper Tories continue their relentless drive to the opposition benches by pursuing issues that divide them from the majority of the Canadian people. From the same Strategic Counsel poll:

The poll shows that 58 per cent of Canadians are against repealing the law that legalized gay marriage, while 36 per cent are for. And 57 per cent do not even want Parliament to vote on whether it should be reopened. The poll surveyed 1,000 Canadians yesterday, and is accurate within 3.1 percentage points, 19 times in 20. The polling in Quebec used a sample of 247 and is considered accurate within 6.3 percentage points, 19 times out of 20.

Sunday, December 03, 2006

Bob Rae Will Run as a Liberal

...in the next federal election.

So says my favorite elfin type, Jason Cherniak; therefore it must be true.

That means Bob is no tourist. Great news, as I think he can still pull some NDP votes even if he's just running for a potential cabinet position. A great catch for the party, anyway.

By the way, a very classy move by him last night--releasing his delegates to vote their conscience and eschewing deals. Also, I am assuming that Ignatieff was "in on" the delay of the fourth ballot results until news time. Big of him, and generally he showed a fair bit of class as well.

I missed Smitherman (I think) saying something rather nasty, but I have not heard the remark replayed. Can anyone enlighten me?

Fat Cop, No Donut

From CTV:

TORONTO -- Jokes about cops and doughnuts might be the reflex reaction to a new survey that shows nearly two-thirds of Toronto Police Service workers are overweight...

Although I am not the one to tell those jokes. For years I swore that a 34 inch waist was where The Great Expansion would end, even if I had to give up both beer and pizza. 34 inches was going to be my "line in the flab", as it were, that would never be crossed. This year, however, my 43rd on the planet, I've surrendered an inch. All my old blue-jeans went into the Goodwill bin before they harmed my testes. Thank God I've stabilized since the Spring; 36" is not yet in sight.

And the weird thing is, when I went in for my annual check-up about a month ago, the doctor's scale said I'd dropped a lb or two. It seems that as I age I am becoming rounder and less dense.

Dion: One Grumpy Old Man's Opinion

Ben Meisner is a columnist/blogger for Opinion250, a radio station out of Prince George, B.C. His take on the Dion victory is the most interesting thing I've read this morning. He thinks, and isn't particularly happy about the fact, that the Dion/Kennedy partnership re-establishes the old Ontario/Quebec Alliance for the Liberal Party:

When Gerrard Kennedy crossed the floor to throw his support behind Stephane Dion, it had all the ear markings of the good olds days. Take 50 to 60 seats in Quebec, marry that to the 45 you get in Toronto along with a few more from the Golden Horseshoe and you have a nice slender majority which allows you to look after the people that you want, Quebec, Toronto and Golden horseshoe.

Will Stephane be a problem for Stephen Harper’s Tories?

Think about it.


Harper has already been courting Quebec trying to grab a few seats in that province. Who has the best chance of picking up votes in Quebec, Harper, or a francophone?

Kennedy is the darling of the City of Toronto, and there is money behind that crew.

[...]

For those who can remember, things haven’t changed much in the last fifty years. Get a francophone from Quebec as Liberal Leader and get a lieutenant from Toronto and you have winner 10 out of 10 times.

Note that he is completely unfazed by the whole "despised in Quebec" line that has occasionally been floated against Dion. And I tend to agree with him in this. Link Byfield was on CBC this morning re. the Alberta Tory leadership race, claiming that Alberta would never vote Liberal Federally as long as one of their own (Harper) led the CPC. Criticize the mind-set behind this thinking all you want, but I suspect it applies to Quebec as much as it does anywhere else. So you can count on a good portion of La Belle Province rallying behind the hometown boy come election time.

Meisner also has interesting ideas concerning Harper's popularity out West:

The people of the west already are feeling uncomfortable with a leader they supported who has failed to return the favour and so Harper’s support is thin. The very same people who elected him are now casting an eye into the sky wondering where they can turn to next.

Hard for me to judge how widespread these sentiments are. But I would note a recent Decima Poll that had the Tories trailing everywhere in Canada outside of Alberta.

Moving Right Along...

From Lifesite, the wording to be introduced in Parliament this week:

That this house call on the government to introduce legislation to restore the traditional definition of marriage without affecting civil unions, and while respecting existing same sex marriages.

Also, from the same source:

OTTAWA, Canada, December 1, 2006 (LifeSiteNews.com) - Status of Women Canada will lose the majority of its offices by April 1, 2007, the Conservative government said Wednesday, in a follow-through to the program of funding cuts announced in this fall’s budget.

Of course not all women's groups oppose the shut-down. REAL Women's Gwen Landolt gives the move a big thumbs up:

"Status of Women is a make-work project for radical feminism,” said Gwen Landolt, national vice-president of REAL Women, in an interview with LifeSiteNews.com.

“All these women were on the government pay to promote an ideology, not to promote women. The vast majority of women today are competent, capable, industrious and are quite able to participate in the economic, social and cultural life of Canada on their own initiative.”

I always like to quote Gwen Landolt, because it gives me an excuse to reference this old post, which covers a speech she gave in 2003, where Gwen accused homosexual activists of supporting abortion rights as a means of instituting One World Government via the United Nations.

Saturday, December 02, 2006

A More Than Adequate Result

And I will be proud to smite Tories on your behalf.

But work on your English. The accent is charming, and in prepared remarks everything is fine. However, having listened to some of your free-form responses to reporter's questions, I have to say that your English really is a bit windy and inefficient. Chretien knew how to communicate, even though his grasp of grammar was awful: he knew how to put what he needed to say simply and concisely. You do better in all the technical aspects of the language, but you have to learn a simpler, more efficient way of putting things.

Another Reason Canada Should Stay Out of Star Wars (Strategic defense Initiative)

...is that the Democrats are back. People forget that support for missile defense in the U.S. is very much confined to the hard core Republican base. Now that Democrats run the House and Senate, and are writing the cheques that fund the U.S. Federal Government, it is likely that the program will be gutted.

So any money Canada might spend preparing for the implementation of the initiative will be wasted...at least until its the Republicans turn again.

Iggy Supporters Evict Little Old Lady!

Specifically, Tory Senator Marjorie LeBreton, who was observing the convention from a balcony when:

...some toughs from the Michael Ignatieff campaign decided to roust her from her last-row seat. They had decided the seats were reserved for their Ignatieff camp buddies. First, they told her to leave. Then they called security. When none of that worked on the tough senior politician, they just got rude.The Ignatieff campaigners stood in front of LeBreton, staring at her. They eventually forced her to move.

Shame, Iggy, shame! Let's not lose this one ugly, shall we?

Iggastrophe!

Yesterday, in a Post entitled They are calling it Iggymentum, Ted, my favorite Iggynaut, and master of all things Iggy, wrote:

I was talking with a few reporters Wednesday night and last night and we all agreed that Ignatieff's first ballot support will likely be about 31-32%. If it is below 30%, then Ignatieff may be in trouble, but if he's got 35% then it's game over.

And then, after Iggy's speech, the rhetorical equivalent of elevator muzak, I look at The Star this morning and I see:

MONTREAL—Michael Ignatieff, the long-time front-runner in the Liberal leadership race, was stuck at a disappointing 29 per cent in the all-important first round of balloting last night.

It's below the 30 per cent he was supposed to have already and well below the 35 per cent mark he needed to show winning-potential momentum.

Trouble in Iggynation? I'm betting on a second round showing of under 25%.


(It's the thong scandal that did him in)