Friday, September 04, 2009

Twitch In The Numbers Or Liberal Momentum?

I dunno. Angus Reid claims that this is the 1st poll conducted after Iggy's Sept. 1 display of political manhood. While most Canadians are opposed (or strongly opposed) to bringing down the ruling Tories , 42% also think its time for a change of goverment (and hey! the Libs are up 2 points). So any "backlash" to such a move seems likely to be confined to the Op-Ed pages of CanWest newspapers.
Details here.

Thursday, September 03, 2009

Stephen Harper's Greatest Hits



Does he hate Canada?

My favorite bit is a nice little quote towards the end about Human Rights being totalitarian, which puts me in mind of Brian Lilley's post today in which he argues that the Lemire Vs. Warman decision from yesterday will become "election fodder". Gawd I hope so. During the Ontario PC leadership race, polls told us what an anti-human rights stance would likely bring.

Short answer: Doom baby, Doom!

Maxime Bernier Strikes Back

From his blog today, a presser:

Saint-Georges-de-Beauce, September 3, 2009 - The daily paper Le Devoir published a tendentious and sensationalist report this morning about the nature of the documents left by former Foreign Affairs minister Maxime Bernier in a private residence more than a year ago.

Gawd she's hot. That is all.

You Figure It Out: Royal Society On Geo-Engineering

A phase space diagram plotting cost vs. effectiveness of the various methods of geo-engineering under consideration as means of averting AGW. From the Royal Society's report on the topic. Note that "air capture" (ie carbon capture from ambient air), Pielke Jr.'s hobbyhorse, works OK but costs alot, and of course Roger Jr. is not happy with that assessment. Further, he seems to suspect a plot against him and his ideas.
Note too that the cheapest and most effective scheme, pumping aerosols into the stratosphere, is a political no-go. Aerosols shot into the sky in one place come down as acid rain in another country. Oopsie.
PS. The title comes from the fact that the reporters covering this story apparently found the diagram above quite confusing.

As Don Martin

...speaks, so too is Don Martin refuted:

Asked which party they would vote for were a federal election held tomorrow, 32.6 per cent of respondents said they would cast their ballots for Stephen Harper's Tories, while the same percentage opted for Michael Ignatieff's Liberals, EKOS said.

[...]

The Liberals have erased a small but persistent lead enjoyed by the Tories throughout most of the summer by improving their fortunes in the battleground province of Ontario, EKOS said.

Maybe Mr. Martin is waiting on one of those "special" Ipsos polls exclusive to CanWest media.

Wednesday, September 02, 2009

CJC On Lemire Case: Wrong In Law

"The Supreme Court of Canada clearly ruled that s. 13 was constitutional long before the penalty provisions were added to it. As such, Mr. Hadjis should have simply ignored the penalty provisions and applied the appropriate cease and desist order against Mr. Lemire," [Joel Richler, CJC National Honourary Legal Counsel] added.

"This action is known as the doctrine of 'reading out' - a well-established practice endorsed by the Supreme Court of Canada under which the portion of a law that may be unconstitutional is edited out but the remaining constitutional elements are applied. Mr. Hadjis should have 'read out' of section 13(1) the penalty provisions and preserved the rest of the section. Mr. Hadjis failed to consider this option, even though the Supreme Court of Canada has been clear that section 13(1) is perfectly constitutional," Richler explained.

"This was a decision by a single member of the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal. We should recall that there have been two previous decisions by the Tribunal that rejected the constitutional challenges to s. 13. In order to clarify the law, we strongly urge the Canadian Human Rights Commission and Mr. Warman to appeal this decision," CJC CEO Bernie Farber said.

Read the rest through the link.

Lemire Ruling: Section 13 Constitutional

The CHRT decision Warman vs. Lemire came down this morning. Don't have much time to write about it today, but a quick response/fake lawyer opinion:

1) S.13(1) itself is safe, ie. constitutional as per the Taylor decision.

2) The various penalty provisions outlined in S.54(1), which I believe were added to the act later on (1998?), taken in conjunction with 13(1), infringed Lemire's rights under 2(b) of the Charter. Commissioner Hadjis felt that the fact that the CHRC pursued Lemire after he had "amended" his behavior and pulled down the offending material was not in accordance with the "conciliatory" nature of the Canadian Human Rights Act. Short term result: Lemire was guilty of breaching S.13 but no remedial order will be issued against him.

3) Don't know how this will affect Abrams vs. Topham and The Radical Press or future S.13 cases. If I were to guess, I would say that in future the CHRC might have to drop cases where the hate messages which inspired the complaint have been removed by their author/publisher. It won't have any effect on the various Warman vs. whoever lawsuits going forward.

Will add more to this when I am able.

Note To Green Party Supporters

...as your party self-immolates, please consider supporting Michael Ignatieff in the upcoming Federal election. It is an unpalatable truth that the Alberta tar sands cannot simply be shut down or wished away, only managed in a fashion more responsible than is currently the case. And, as the NDP proved in the last Federal and B.C. Provincial elections, they are too beholden to their Union base to push for the kinds of measures necessary to green our automobile, lumber and etc. industries.

And as for Mr. Hertzog, who writes

In attempting to be just like all the other parties in the belief that this will get a single Green MP elected, the Green Party of Canada has thrown out its principles in its bid for power.

...well, principles are lovely in the abstract but under the circumstances this is nothing more than the expression of a political death wish. Without Elizabeth May the federal Green Party is nothing, and if the federal Green Party itself is a factor in her failing to gain a seat in the HOC next election, then the Green Party will lose Elizabeth May. You people will be back to raising money by holding salmon bakes and selling mushrooms, less a political party than a cult of aging hippies running around the gulf islands in Jesus robes and eating roots and berries. D'you want that?

PS. I think she should have run here, by the way. I could see May easily adding another 10% to Nagy's total.

Meanwhile, Out In Alberta


From the campaign of Mark Dyrholm, who is running for leader of Alberta's Wildrose Alliance Party, which has drawn the support of the the separatist Western Business and Taxpayers Association (WBTA) and other Alberta luminaries.

Tuesday, September 01, 2009

Mulclair Resurrects Purple Coalition

Jack and Steve 's Campaign Sweaters
From the Canadian Press:

...MP Thomas Mulcair immediately offered a most girly form of surrender.

"What I'm saying is: the last thing Canadians want is a fourth general election in five years especially as we in the NDP would get slaughtered and we'd better have a bloody good reason for forcing a fourth general election in five years because we would get slaughtered.

"So if Mr. Harper goes about being provocative as he has been in the past, going after key things that Canadians hold dearly like women's rights and the environment, then we'll surrender most girly like because he'll have provoked it.

"If, on the other hand, Stephen Harper comes into Parliament and abuses our asses, then we're going to take it on a case-by-case basis and eventually our caucus will offer its most girly form of surrender."

Some people say when you mix NDP orange and Tory blue you get a purply pink. I say its a pinky purple. But whatever.

What The Hell Does It Mean?

Michael Ignatieff has decided his Liberals will no longer support the Harper government, sources say.

But that doesn't mean he'll move quickly to bring the minority Conservatives down either.

Not that I doubt...no,no, I do not doubt. Iggy knows all, sees all. His gloriousness is both transplendant and transfinite, and though I wish only clarity and yet see no clarity in this statement, it is surely a problem with myself and not the party. I am truly weak, and only another $50 donation to the party will make me strong again.

Yes, yes. Strength and certainty. I need to look at that picture of Iggy shaking his fist again.

There, I am better now.

Update: Clarity?

Sources have told CTV News that the Liberals will put forward a non-confidence motion to force an election this fall -- although they need the support of the NDP and the Bloc Quebecois for that to happen

Further Clarity! Click through to the Globe story above and the line about "not moving quickly" has disappeared.

Hottest August Ever?

Maybe not quite but, according to the UAH website, among the hottest on record and much hotter than last year even though, if you are going by sunspot numbers, the Sun has been dead as a doornail.

According to AGW deniers though, it isn't supposed to be that way.

Stockwell Day On Senate Reform: Reforming The Upper Chamber One Hack At A Time

In his most recent weekly column, the Minister of International Trade Stockwell Day chimes in on the topic of Senate reform, and in particular Prime Minister Harper's latest round of appointments. Here are some column highlights, followed by my own brief remarks:

Then there's the little (big) matter of being unelected. The Prime Minister has invited Premiers to come up with a way of getting their own citizens to elect the person of their choice within their own province. Then the Prime Minister will promise to put them in the Senate.

However, the suggested mechanisms by which a province would put forward its choice for a vacant Senate seat are joke-worthy at best. In all of proposals put forward by the Harper Tories, for example, winning a senate election would not necessarily result in assuming a senate seat. Their first crack at reform took place back at the end of 2006. At that time, The Ottawa Citizen reported:

... the [Conservative] bill proposes to establish a procedure where Elections Canada, which has the legal authority to conduct a federal referendum as well as federal elections, would conduct a form of plebiscite, likely only within provinces that have Senate vacancies.

The results would be presented as information to a prime minister to consider when filling a vacancy.

The consultation could not be legally binding on Harper or subsequent prime ministers because the Constitution stipulates only the Queen, on the advice of cabinet, can name people to the Senate. Unlike all other government appointments, where the Governor General's approval is enough, Senate appointments continue to receive direct approval from the Queen.

Even in the case of Bert Brown, who Albertans chose as their upper chamber representative in 2007, the actual appointment was, in the end, a result of a Prime Ministerial whim:

So far only Alberta has responded by coming up with their own Senate election. They allow for the names of Senate candidates to be added to the ballots during their municipal elections. The province picks up the administration costs and the people decide who their Senator will be.

The last time they did this the winner was Bert Brown. The Prime Minister kept his word and appointed him to the Senate. He sits today in that Chamber, quite proud to be the only elected Senator in that place of over 100 appointees.

Had the Prime Minister chosen to break his word, something he has been occasionally occasionally to do, the people of Alberta would have come up with bupkis.

This problem is exacerbated by the fact that there is no mechanizsm to determine who can offer themselves as a Senate candidate. So, with most reform proposals under consideration, I could put myself forward. And if I won, the Prime Minister could ignore the result. A good outcome, I suppose, but achieved only via an absurd process.

Mr. Day also considers the PM's most recent attempts at reform:

To deal with the problem of it being a life-long position the Prime Minister takes an innovative approach. Whomever the Prime Minister appoints must vow to step down after 8 years, no exceptions, no excuses. So each person he recently appointed, along with the ones he appointed earlier, will be done in 8 years. That's a major change.

No, it is a reform technique that is only as good as the vows of the appointees. Not to be too cynical, but the odds of a Conservative government still being in power federally in 8 years is low, the odds of Stephen Harper heading up that government are infinitesimal. And, either way, if any of his Senate appointees wish to remain in the upper chamber past that date, there is not a thing he or anyone else can do about it.

Mr. Day concludes

One more thing about the latest round of Senate appointees, each one has agreed to work hard from inside the Senate to push for reform. That means when the next federal election is called we may see senators stepping down from the Red Chamber and running for office.

That's progress.

Yeah, or we may not see anything like that, in which case we have the status quo passed off as progress.

Monday, August 31, 2009

Cash Overboard!

I'm sure this didn't come out quite the way Barrie MP Patrick Brown wanted it to.

Out The Conservatives Day Swiftly Approaches

Connie and Co. at Free Dominion, after having been disappointed time after time by the Harper government re free speech issues, finally blew a gasket over the Investigative Powers for the 21st Century (IP21C) Act--which would force ISPs to disclose subscriber information such as name and address, and grant the police broad new powers to obtain transmission data and force ISPs to preserve data--and decided to strike back. Back in July, Connie wrote:

My proposal is that, if this government insists on doing this[IP21C], we strip them of their anonymity, too.

Every blogger and forum owner in Canada should begin compiling a list of usernames that have been used by IP addresses owned by the Conservative Party of Canada or the House of Commons, and we should set a day for a collective "reveal".

Well, I haven't followed the latest on IP21C, but it looks like the gang at FreeD is still...displeased...and it looks like a tentative reveal date has been set:

The 14th of September is nearing.....the day the house resumes sitting and the action begins...

...says ToryCanuck, one of their stalwarts.

Interesting to see what they can pull from their hats. Connie admits that Tory operatives have been pushing propoganda out through the message board for years. If they really can link pseuds to meat world interfaces, who knows what may follow?

Sunday, August 30, 2009

Ryan Doyle Replaces Dumped Michael Coren On CFRB

From Tarek Fatah's Facebook page:

Tarek Fatah survived the storm at CFRB and will continue to co-host the 3-4PM hour with Ryan Doyle. Stay tuned.

Ryan who? And is he more or less fucked up in the head than Michael Coren?

Olivia Chow Threatened

...for handing out fliers at a Toronto town hall copyright forum. The forum, part of the federal government's consultation process as it prepares new copyright legislation, was meant to facilitate discussion of issues surrounding this legislation from the various stake-holders. The fliers contained an interview with NDP MP Charlie Angus in which he called for "balanced" copyright legislation, but when Ms. Chow attempted to distribute this material, private security personnel hired by the event organizers--who appear to have been entertainment industry shills-- told her to lay off or be removed from the hotel at which the consultation was being held.

Members of the Canadian Federation of Students were also set upon for distributing similar material. Their news release re the incident can be found here.

This Is One Anonymous Liberal Source I Can Get Behind

“Even if the Liberals haven't made up their minds about wanting an election, [it's] good to see they have their act together this early.”

I don't think the party ever really got its act together under Dion. At least Ignatieff has the Liberal machine turning over smoothly. Its a start.

Saturday, August 29, 2009

Into The Senate And Off The Hook

Has anyone else is the anglo media or blogosphere picked up on Buzzetti's point? That Doug Finley's newfound parliamentary immunity will allow him to avoid testifying re. the Cons electoral fraud?

From here. Translation of Buzzetti below:

" As for the nomination of Mr. Finley to the Senate, it will have another consequence. Being from now on a member of Parliament, one will not be able to require of him qu' any more; he appears before a committee of the House of Commons for qu' he explains his role in the strategy of electoral financing of the Conservative party in 2006. Mr. Finley is famous being the brain of the mechanism known as of “in and out”, stratagem by which the conservatives are suspected of having spent 1 million dollars moreover than the allowed electoral limit. This cause is always in front of the courts, but the deputies in Ottawa tried l' summer last to hold of the audiences on this subject and any preserving apparatchik n' condescended to present itself, in spite of the assignments to appear been useful in certain cases. Mr. Finley, slinger, s' was presented two days before the date envisaged by requiring d' to be heard immediately, without what it would not return. He had been escorted by the security service. "

Not sure if that helps or not.

Total Confusion In Alberta...

...over bill 44, an update to the province's human rights legislation. A minister-on-minister dust up seems to have occurred between Education Minister Dave Hancock and Culture Minister Lindsay Blackett.

Background: teachers are still worried they might be taken to the Alberta Human Rights Commision for, among other things, discussing sexuality in class without having informed parents in advance, so that said parents might decide whether or not their children are allowed to participate in the discussion or even attend.

Education minister Hancock asked that implementation of this "parental opt-out" clause be delayed until next year and...what?

This story from five hours ago suggests that Blackett has agreed to the delay. This one, from a bit earlier in the day, suggests he still wants to press ahead. So I don't know what the heck is going on, but its sure no way to run a rail-road, let alone a province aspiring to national leadership.

I will make a prediction though: I predict that the opt-out clause eventually comes out of the legislation entirely, and we are left with a document that explicitly disallows discrimination on the basis of sexuality.

Update: Blackett tweets:

Section 9 will take effect on Sept 1, 2010 so formalized process can be created by School Boards.