Tuesday, July 14, 2009

More On The News Cycle

From the Journalism Lab, more commentary on Meme-tracking and the Dynamics of the News Cycle. Here the J-Lab author (Zachary M. Seward) disputes the contention (ascribed to the NY Times but really straight from the paper itself) that blogs follow the MSM (as shown in figure above):

The authors describe this as a “‘heartbeat’-like dynamic” or a series of handoffs between blogs and mainstream media. My hunch is that the heartbeat would be even more visible — healthier, you might say — if the study had made a more-precise distinction between mainstream media and blogs. But in any event, the finding explodes that worn-out notion, furthered by today’s Times piece, of parasitic blogs merely reacting to the work of professional journalists.

This suggests the possibility that news is typically "found" by the blogosphere (the early blip on less prominent sites), and then widecast by the MSM, and then, finally, further chewed over one more time in the blogs. Here's the relevant passage from the paper:

Figure 9 shows a “heartbeat”-like like dynamics where the phrase “oscillates” between blogs and mainstream media. The fraction of blog volume is initially constant, but it turns upward about three hours before the peak as early bloggers mention the phrase. Once the news media joins in, around t = 􀀀1, the fraction of blog volume drops sharply; but it then jumps up after t = 0 once the news media begins dropping the thread and blogs continue adopting it...

The question I have: do the early media reports typically precede or follow the early blog reports?

Another thing I've noticed is that the original paper's discussion of the 3.5% of stories in which the MSM appears to follow the blogs (in the top graph, the green line would peak 1s in such cases) is a bit obscure. The paper's table 2 give several examples, one of which is:

Well uh you know I think that whether you’re looking at it from a theological perspective or uh a scientific perspective uh answering that question with specificity uh you know is uh above my pay grade.

This is a response from now-President Obama to a question posed by him in an interview with Rick Warren. But it does not appear to me to show a piece of news discovered in the blogosphere, and then launched into the MSM. Rather, the interview was quite heavily covered in the MSM (at least as I remember it), which is where the original phrase would have appeared. It was the percieved inadequacy of Obama's response that got batted about the blogosphere, and was then recirculated through the major news outlets.

So it doesn't answer the (to me) important question: how much primary news are bloggers getting to 1st (in which direction does the 1st handoff go--from blogs to MSM or MSM to blogs)?

Monday, July 13, 2009

The Kids Are Alright--They Think Twitter Sucks!

This wisdom of 15 year old Morgan Stanley summer work intern Matthew Robson, whose report, How Teenagers Consume Media, has become a Industry sensation:

On Music

[Teenagers] are very reluctant to pay for [music] (most never having bought a CD) and a large majority (8/10) downloading it illegally from file sharing sites. Legal ways to get free music that teenagers use are to listen to the radio, watch music TV channels (not very popular, as these usually play music at certain times, which is not always when teenagers are watching) and use music streaming websites (as I entioned previously).

[...]

A number of people use the music service iTunes (usually in conjunction with iPods) to acquire their music (legally) but again this is unpopular with many teenagers because of the ‘high price’ (79p per song). Some teenagers use a combination of sources to obtain music, because sometimes the sound quality is better on streaming sites but they cannot use these sites whilst offline, so they would download a song then listen to it on music streaming sites (separate from the file).

On Social Networking & Twitter


Most teenagers are heavily active on a combination of social networking sites. Facebook is the most common, with nearly everyone with an internet connection registered and visiting >4 times a week. Facebook is popular as one can interact with friends on a wide scale. On the other hand, teenagers do not use twitter. Most have signed up to the service, but then just leave it as they release that they are not going to update it (mostly because texting twitter uses up credit, and they would rather text friends with that credit). In addition, they realise that no one is viewing their profile, so their ‘tweets’ are pointless.

Newspapers

No teenager that I know of regularly reads a newspaper, as most do not have the time and cannot be bothered to read pages and pages of text while they could watch the news summarised on the internet or on TV.

The only newspapers that are read are tabloids and freesheets (Metro, London Lite…) mainly because of cost

Cinema

... it is possible to buy a pirated DVD of the film at the time of release, and these cost much less than a cinema ticket so teenagers often choose this instead of going to the cinema.

Mobile Phones

As most teenagers’ phones have Bluetooth support, and Bluetooth is free, they utilise this feature often. It is used to send songs and videos (even though it is illegal) and is another way teenagers gain songs for free.

On HD TV

However, many are not utilising this HD functionality, as HD channels are expensive extras which many families cannot justify the added expenditure. Many of them don’t want to sign up to HD broadcasting services, as adverts are shown on standard definition broadcasts, so they can’t see the difference.

Note here, and in the original report, how often the word "free" comes up. And, frankly, with respect to movies, tunes, and TVs, I can see little difference between teen and adult behavior. Nobody I know (mostly 30 to 50-ish) has bought music in years.

Which Way The News Flows

This paper, Meme-tracking and the Dynamics of the News Cycle, in which computer scientists from Cornell and Stanford tracked a series of short phrases appearing in the news cycle and observed their journey back and forth between MSM and blogosphere, certainly looks worth further study. But the quick take away message:

1) Phrases appear in the MSM on average 2.5 hours before they show up in the blogosphere. That is, the "news" tends to be "discovered" by real journalists, and then propagated further, at a slight lag, by the blogosphere.

2) Only about 3.5% of news stories move from blogs initially and then into the MSM.

Well, I was rather hoping "we" would be doing a bit better. But the dinosaurs still rule, it seems.

The meme-tracker in question can be found here.

(Haven't read the paper closely enough to see if this would actually pan out, but 2 1/2 hours is about the time between when most bloggers read their news in the morning and the time they write about it.)

Sunday, July 12, 2009

It's Called Mogadishu

Nichols asks: What country in the world has unregulated capitalism? Let me know and I'll move there.

...and I will gladly pay your ticket, if you don't like Canada.

More shocked and appalled!!!! out of The Right based on S. Harper's embrace of One World Government.

Ogopogo...Or No?

A picture taken in 1985 and now on Cryptomundo, where the general consensus seems to be "no". Also in the news: Ogopogo carcass found?

I'm betting "no" on that one too.

Always Click On The Links

A quick experiment with The Ez:

The Privacy Commissioner did not investigate whether or not the CHRC hacked Nelly Hechme's Internet account. They merely investigated whether, while hacking Hechme's account, the CHRC kept any of her personal information. Here's the exact wording of the mandate of the Privacy Commissioner's investigation:

The purpose of the investigation was to examine whether the CHRC improperly collected, used, disclosed or retained personal information about the complainant during the course of its investigations, in contravention of sections 4 to 8 of the Privacy Act.

And here's the bit Ezra leaves out, which should go at the head of the previous paragraph:

Investigation finds no evidence that Canadian Human Rights Commission accessed individual's Internet connection

One must access to hack, no?

Anyway, you can play the same game with all of Ezra's links, but it gets pretty boring, as you keep getting the same result.

Sorry, Ezra, the jig's up. Your future lies in bashing the food cops.

Saturday, July 11, 2009

Harper Backs OWG!



Also notable for how Tony Clement plays Flavor Flav to Harper's Chuck D. This clip is already circulating in the U.S. right-wing nut-o-sphere as an example of how our leaders have sold out. (Stephen Harper meets Al Gore! and etc.)

T.O Garbage Strike Nears End?

The word I'm hearing is that the city is starting to cave.

For one thing, while its been hard on the strikers, the management staff replacing them has been working 7 day weeks and pulling double-shifts to keep it all together. And if you've been posted to one of the dump-sites, you're basically facing a gang of angry garbage-men--shirtless under the hot sun, their torsos well-oiled with manly sweat--who have been pitching bags of kitchen waste at you for two plus weeks (the union takes garbage from citizens and then "transfers" it to management staff, sometimes violently).

But the most important factor is: Scotia Bank doesn't want to get stuck with the clean-up tab for Caribana, and word has been going around in the local Caribbean community that the whole thing has been cancelled. That's not true, yet, but the city doesn't want to lose a week's worth of tourist business, so they're looking for a negotiating out. My wife tells me she may even be back at work this week if the union thinks there is something viable on the table. Sounds serious, too; she's been a lot happier the past couple of days and has started shopping again.

If not, well, she received weapons training with her picket sign at the big UAW rally on Thursday. People with trash to drop off may want to avoid Bermondsey. She prefers a two-handed grip.


(PS. Unions has rejected latest city offer, put counter-offer on table.)

Tim Hudak's Statement

...re the dissolution of the Barrie PC riding group.

When Tim Hudak makes some response to the dissolution of the Barrie PC riding group, we will report on that response. So far nothing.

Meanwhile, one of the guys being charged is still Facebook friends with Frank Klees and several other PCPO notables.

h/t Bourque, who is presumably off the payroll.

Little more info here.

Dalton McGuinty Can Sleep Sound Tonight

PC riding group shelved after sex raps surface

Friday, July 10, 2009

Gordon Smith Is Not Iggy

Got it! This quote

...it is really important that Canada be on top this because otherwise ... somebody will come up with the idea of creating an entirely new group. A group that would certainly include key countries like China and India, but no particular reason why it would include Canada.

...comes originally from here. Iggy speaks for a bit, then Gordon Smith (Center For Global Studies)takes over and says the words in question. I imagine the e-mail Mr. Dimitri Soudas recieved was a transcript, because that's a picture of Mr. Smith there. Not at all like Iggy.

Remarks in question at about the 3:40 mark.

Pirate Party In The News

My post from last Saturday is in The Mark. Its conclusion:

Who stands to lose if the Pirate Party decides to invade our shores? You would think they would skim votes off the hapless NDP, but at the same time, Michael Geist himself has speculated that copyright reform brought out many traditional non-voters during the 2008 election, and there is even a libertarian slice of the Conservative Party that might be swayed by their message.

While it's highly unlikely the Pirates would be able to win a seat in the House of Commons anytime soon, they might well – like the Green Party – be able to effect some degree of policy change from outside of that venue.

The editors changed "perennially hapless NDP" to just "hapless NDP", but whatever. Still no money involved, though when you read in its new context, the piece just oozes credibility. Interesting note from the comments of my original post:

They will have about as much effect as the marijuana party did, which, it should be stated, was a lot. The Liberals took up decrim in 2003 partly because they were seeping so many votes to the marijuana party. Nowadays, most parties support marijuana decrim and the party has little reason to exist any more. Parties can be an amazingly powerful pressure groups to influence mainstream parties. So yes, a Pirate Party is a good idea even if it stands no chance of picking up a seat.

So Is Brad Trost Now Distributing Marquee Tourism Event Funds?

SoCons gone rogue, it looks like:

Saskatoon-Humboldt MP Brad Trost isn't backing away from a statement he made to an anti-abortion website earlier this week about Toronto's Pride Week being a polarizing and political event that should not have received federal funding.

And here's the kicker:

Trost said he was aware the federal government, under Canadian Heritage, funded Saskatoon's Pride Festival in June with a $9,000 grant to the Saskatoon Diversity Network.

"I've been aware of it. I'm a fiscal conservative so I've been urging reductions all across the board on all sorts of issues, not just on heritage funding," he said.

The MP said he hasn't reviewed all of the Canadian events that have received funding through MTEP, but so far Toronto Pride Week appears to be the only one he thinks should not have received federal dollars.

"I haven't actually looked through the whole entire list, but it may be that this one is the unique one," he said. "I've seen about a partial list of what was funded through this program, but not a complete list."

Trost hopes MTEP eventually expands to fund smaller events such as local parades.

So now we've got your prototype of a back-bench nobody pontificating on where government ministers should be dispensing funds. All when the boss is overseas.

Anyway, Trost's interview winds up with a mini panic attack:

After the interview was over, Trost accused the StarPhoenix reporter of "ambushing" him with questions about the issue and pressed the stop button on her voice recorder.

Thanks to Mr. Trost for keeping this alive into day four. Looks like my work on the file is done. I would just remind readers that, painful as it is to read, the Lifesite should be on your regular visit list. If you want to chase down political crazies, you have to go where the crazy people go.

Thursday, July 09, 2009

World Travel Watch: Stay Outta T.O.


Other destinations on the "Don't Go There!" list include North Africa and Honduras. Under mayor Miller, Toronto really has become "world class".

Harper At The G-8

G-8, G-20...who cares? When you gotta go, you gotta go.

(PS. Who'd have thought I would be able to use the same gag twice in one year?)

Dean Steacy Gets Another Opportunity To Sue People

Russ Hiebert, Conservative nobody for South Surrey-White Rock-Cloverdale, repeats charges to the effect that Mr. Steacy committed a criminal act:

Further, uncontradicted expert evidence presented before the hearing demonstrated that investigator Steacy illegitimately used an unsuspecting private citizen's wireless Internet service to post his offensive comments.

...charges that the RCMP and Privacy Commission dismissed several months back.

And the fact that Hiebert's piece seems as though it was ghost-written by Ezra (note the "uncontradicted...evidence" silliness that appears several times on Levant's blog) doesn't help Mr. Hiebert's claim that he is building his case from tribunal documents.

And, finally, a note to Mr. Steacy: sue these pricks. Sue as many of them as you want. I'll put up a donation button and slip you $5 myself.

Buckets gives Mr. Hiebert a thorough deconstructing here.

HRCs Cleared Again!

Comments re HRC "abuse" of power pulled from CRTC policy opinion. Opinion's author clearly read Shakedown a 2nd time, realized--"Hey! This is all bullshit!" Speechies left sucking rocks. Booyah!

Wednesday, July 08, 2009

Do They Hate Gays, Or Just Torontonians, Or Just Gay Torontonians?

But in his criticism of his colleague, [Brad Trost] did not mention his government funds Saskatoon's Pride parade. The Saskatoon Diversity Network received $9,000 from Canadian Heritage this year for last June's Pride Festival.

h/t Roy in comments.

Anyone know if Trost appeared at this?

Brad The Impaler

When he's not sticking it to his fellow Tories, how does Brad Trost, Conservative Member of Parliament for the riding of Saskatoon—Humboldt, spend his days?

Trying to defund International Planned Parenthood, of course. He's got a petition to the HOC going that would cut their government funding. One thing he's pissed off about:

The IPPF does not support physicians' freedom to practice according to their conscience and/or religious beliefs regarding abortion referral.

Note we're talking abortion referral here, not abortion per se. Brad thinks Christian docs should be able to refuse to even tell women seeking abortions where they might get one. IPP's declaration on the matter reads:

5.3 Health care professionals have the right to conscientious objection with regard to providing contraception and abortion services only if they can refer the client to health professionals willing to provide the service immediately. No such right exists in emergency cases where lives are at risk.

But that ain't good enough for Brad.

Note that IPP is funded through CIDA (Canadian International Development Agency). That's Bev Oda's department...for now. Keep your head down, Bev.

Is The Calgary Stampede Next?

After Diane Ablonczy got herself politically perished for handing out government cash to the gays, the Harper Tories are moving to ensure something like that doesn't happen again: