Monday, September 14, 2009

On The New Head Of The Canadian Human Rights Tribunal

The Honourable Rob Nicholson, P.C. Q. C., M.P. for Niagara Falls, Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada, today announced the appointment of Shirish P. Chotalia, Q.C., as Chair of the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal.

Ms. Chotalia is an fascinating choice, given the current state of the Speechy conflict. For one thing, in 2003 she was one of the three member CHRT panel that oversaw Richard Warman's very first Section 13 complaint (Richard Warman and the CHRC vs. Fred Kyburz), which resulted in Warman's being awarded $30,000 for death threats made against him by the respondent. (As an aside, one of the witnesses called during proceedings was Karen Mock, a lawyer for B'nai Brith--among other things--and these days the Liberal Party candidate for Thornhill.) And in 2007, Ms. Chotalia attempted to convince Alberta's Attorney General to press hate incitement charges against the diplomats at the Calgary Chinese Consulate for distributing anti-Falun Gong propaganda.

BUT: she has also spoke before the Chumir Ethics Foundation, who currently stand in opposition to section 13 and its provincial counterparts, although they have done so in a manner far more responsible than Ezra and the rest of his crew. And earlier, as a member of the Alberta's Civil Liberties Association, she demanded "a clearer definition of what the RCMP can and cannot do during its investigations".

An interesting resume, and proof I suppose that a real human life can straddle all sides of an issue.

Sunday, September 13, 2009

Justin Is A Great Canadian (And BCL Rules OK In The Soo)

"Someone should give Justin Tetreault - who filmed Harper's speech in the Soo and who used to blog as the Northern Ontario Liberal - the Order of Canada," adds Toronto blogger M.J. Murphy. "He may have saved his nation from four more years of Conservative rule."

I stand by this comment. JT exposed the Tory government's great lie--that they are really moderates, not just faking it for the newscasts. How can you do that if you can't show film of them in their natural habitat? In any case, there was apparently no "no camera" rule in place.

And I'll tell you what, the remarks by SooToday.com editorialists David Root and Mac Headrick are baloney. If Satan himself had walked up to these two and handed them the tape on the end of his pitchfork--and then said: "Hey fellas, let's get something straight, I am indeed Satan."--they would, as journalists, have accepted the tape and run with the story. Guarenteed.

Of course they would probably have bitched about Satan afterwards, behind his back.

How Many Teabags

...does it take to march on Washington?

2,000,000
estimated... at 1.5 million, but that was unlikely
300,000 expected
...in excess of 75,000
50,000 attendees at about 10 a.m.
...approximately 60,000 to 70,000 people flooded Pennsylvania Ave
...25000 to 50000 demonstrators are expected to gather*

(*)Note that this last figure is based on organizers expectations as of September 9th. The idea that they would underestimate their own people by even a factor of five or ten is pretty unlikely.

And 50,000 to 75,000 is what U2 would play at a typical concert.

Harper Government Prepares To Hike Payroll Tax

Because that's what "overcollecting" the payroll tax amounts to. Certainly the effect is identical to a tax hike:

“If they're looking at reducing the deficit by increasing the premiums...it will slow down the hiring process,” Mr. [Jason] Myers [president of Canadian Manufacturers & Exporters] said.

In fact, it appears that Jim Flaherty will rely almost entirely on an increase in EI premiums to bring the country out of its current deficit position. That's it. There's nothing else in Thursdays economic update that could be accurately described as an element in some deficit reduction plan.

Interesting to see the NDP response to this going forward. Jack Layton seems willing to wear the purple sweater, to "make parliament work", as they say, in exchange for some tiny little political bone related to changes in the EI system. An increase to the payroll tax was precisely not what he had in mind.

Saturday, September 12, 2009

Dinner With Rob Anders

Looks like Rob Anders has attempted a little fence-mending, after trashing Calgary's Muslim community in one of his 10 per centers.

Anders attended a ramadan dinner at the Calgary Islamic Centre Friday night to try and defend his actions.

On the other hand, there was free food involved....

Bjørn Lomborg To Lose State Funding?

Conservative Party climate spokesman Per Ørum Jørgensen said the government should consider if it was paying for Lomborg to go to Greenland and tell people there that it was fine not to support a climate agreement at the conference in Copenhagen.

Jørgensen was referring to Lomborg’s trip to Greenland in August when he praised the country’s stance that if a climate deal did not allow developing nations to advance industrially it would not support it.

Lomborg has been providing the Denialist community with pseudo-science talking points for years now. My favorite is probably here, where he claims that things will work out fine for the polar bear if it only learns to to evolve backwards.

Wow That Was Quick!

The anonymous dude with the private basement war-room has already forged Stephen Harper's "Hidden Agenda Speech" into an attack ad:

Looks like the anonymous dude has managed to steal some half decent editing software, because the production values on this one are are definitely good enough for TIFF. But for me there's something missing. For me, any ad about Stephen Harper should include this portrait, in which his face is illuminated by the very flames of Hell itself, from which place he emerged so many years ago.
Get with it, anonymous dude.

Friday, September 11, 2009

Wafergate Wind Up: He's Back, Where's She?

The company also announced the reinstatement of Jamie Irving as vice-president, about six weeks after he left the Telegraph-Journal as publisher when the newspaper issued its apology to the prime minister.

Irving will be in charge of the newspapers' daily operations, but will report to Reynolds on editorial matters and journalistic practices.

The boss' son always gets off easy.

Beenie Man Comes To Canada

Beenie Man is best known for his rabidly homophobic lyrics. I remember back in 2004 protests forced the cancellation of several of his Ontario concerts , but it looks like he's been in town this year without much incident, and it looks like he's back tonight.

Here's the rest of his Canadian dates:

Fri 09/11/09 Toronto, ON Lot 322
Sat 09/12/09 Oshawa, ON Big Sexy Sun
09/13/09 Ottawa, ON TBA
Mon 09/14/09 Toronto, ON Fluid
Wed 09/16/09 Halifax, NS Paragon Theatre
Thu 09/17/09 London, ON Club Large
Sat 09/19/09 Montreal, QC EB Lounge Sun
09/20/09 Laval, QC Red Lite

Thank You Tories

It is as though they saw themselves getting a little bit ahead in the polls and thought "This isn't really fair is it? Lets do some really stupid stuff to give the Liberal Party a boost!", like:

1) have their glorious leader give a secret speech in which he embraces his Reform Party roots, calls 70% of the nation commies, and puts the repeal of the gun registry front and center in any upcoming election campaign:

...the Conservatives are bent on dismantling the registry - they have three different bills that are before Parliament, they have renewed the amnesty for failing to register and the Prime Minister has been working closely with gun lobby groups to mobilize supporters. While a vocal minority opposes the law, the fact remains, that the registry has been working to make Canada safer. Police use it thousands of times each day and gun deaths in Canada have declined dramatically. Harper is trying to appeal to his base in rural Canada, while presenting a kinder, gentler face to urban votes, women and Quebec. But the message is clear, with a Conservative majority we will lose the gains we have made since the Montreal massacre twenty years ago.

...and 2) offer one of the most pathetic attempts at an "economic update" the nation has ever seen, in which, instead of actually outlining the steps the government will take to stem the flow of red ink, the Finance Minister says things are bad, bad, bad, and the nation will be up to its eye-balls in deficits and debt for longer than anyone can possibly predict. And, just to help spin the media reps he wants to tell all this stuff to, he locks them in a room for two hours before the big reveal.

And it was all voluntary on Mr. Flaherty's part! He didn't have to do any of this stuff!

I just hope team Liberal isn't sitting around thinking that they should return the favour. You know, like: "Next time Iggy gives a speech on Environmental policy, lets have him set his tie on fire!"

Finally, someone should give Justin Tetreault-- who filmed Harper's speech in the Soo, and who used to blog as the Northern Ontario Liberal--the Order of Canada. He may have saved his nation from four more years of Conservative rule. I mean, what did Nancy Green do to get her snowflake? She skied down a hill! That's it!

Thursday, September 10, 2009

More NDP Weakness

From Tory whip Jay Hill:

For the second time in a year, Mr. Ignatieff has thrown Jack Layton a curve ball. First Mr. Ignatieff, who had signed-up for a Liberal-NDP-Bloc coalition just days after Canadians returned our Conservative Government to power with a stronger mandate, reneged on the deal. Now, Mr. Ignatieff has called Mr. Layton’s election bluff.

Back in June when the Liberals were ducking Parliamentary votes to avoid an election they didn’t have the money to fight, Mr. Layton could boast he would never support the Conservative Government. He even bragged that the NDP voted against us in 79 consecutive confidence motions in the House.

In August following a meeting with Prime Minister Stephen Harper, a defiant Mr. Layton declared, “The NDP would be the least likely of the political parties to support the Conservatives in office.”

Yet when Mr. Ignatieff suddenly put the election trigger in his hands in early September, Mr. Layton, who is typically the first politician to throw himself in front of a television camera, went into hiding for two days! He sent his deputy leader, Thomas Muclair to deliver an olive branch to our Conservative government, suggesting the NDP would work with us on a case-by-case basis.

On one hand, the NDP are showing poorly in the polls and in their bank balance so Mr. Layton is hedging his bets by now pretending to be conciliatory and cooperative in Parliament. On the other hand, he doesn’t want to waste a rare opportunity for himself and the NDP to be relevant in Canadian politics. So he’s also trying to play the role of ‘power-broker’ by echoing Mr. Ignatieff’s election threats.


Meanwhile, Western Arctic NDP MP Dennis Bevington is willing to don the NDP/CPoC purple sweater of alliance:

While Harper wrote off the idea of working with the NDP shortly after Ignatieff made his comments, Bevington said a coalition was "plausible."

"We didn't support them in their original budget - the Liberals did. The arrangement was between the Liberals and the Conservatives. The Liberals have abandoned that arrangement," he said. "That doesn't mean that we have to have an election now. Prime Minister Harper needs to give a little room to some of the things that we see, or the Bloc see, that are correct. Those are things that he has to do."

If Harper is willing to make compromises, his government will survive, Bevington said.

"If he simply says, 'Well, I'm going to do what I want to do,' then it will be a very difficult situation."

Ah, but difficult for whom, Mr. Bevington, difficult for whom?

An Interesting Note On Hypothetical Elections

Had the Harper Tories not chosen to ignore, or perhaps break, their own law re fixed election dates, we would be having an election this fall (October 19th, 2009)

Just saying.

Blunting Their Own Momentum

Most of the buzz this morning is about the super secret Harper speech. All the elements of the Tory Secret Agenda--bashing the judiciary, putting the repeal of the gun registry front and center--they're all here. Give them a Majority, and these guys will teach everyone a lesson.

The anonymous dude from a private basement war-room somewhere has sent this little reminder of what you'll get more of when you get a Tory Majority.

Oooh! Oooh! I See An Election Issue Right Here!!!

Its true! New Tory Environment Plan Coddles Blue Eyed Sheiks, Screws Over Rest Of Country!

Wednesday, September 09, 2009

Linda Leatherdale Is Back

I don't usually have enough bad things to say about the T.O. Sun and other like newspapers, but I've spent enough time on the phone with Linda over the years to be happy for her:

She's baaaaack. Linda Leatherdale, ousted from her longtime job as Money Editor in December, returns to the Toronto Sun this Friday and Sunday in a Homes-Extra.ca fall new homes and condos preview section. The Sun's Money section hasn't been the same without her.

Meanwhile, prepare for the battle of the free newspapers. T.o.night went live yesterday, and 24 gave itself a face-lift to prepare. It's The Sun vs. ex-Sun employees.

Given The Stink Over Ruby Dhalla

...that the Tories raised, even summoning a number of care-givers groups to their cause, this is barf-worthy. They've essentially nixed any meaningful changes to the Live-In Caregiver Program (LCP). In fact, if you think Ruby Dhalla was guilty of something in the way of sub-standard employment practices, then you should be especially enraged. The government's current position actually tilts the playing field away from employer accountability (bolds are mine):

The government seems to think continuing to put employers first will protect migrant workers in the program.

[...]

The government takes this thinking to a new extreme in their plans to reintroduce Bill C_45, which is similar in vein to the controversial Bill-C50 passed in June. Adoption of the bill will give the “legal authority to deny entry to Canada to foreign workers who could be exposed to exploitation or abuse”. Thus, the government acknowledges the dangers to workers. Yet, the government is not seeking the authority to monitor employers, but rather, the government wants to deport workers, if the employers are untrustworthy.


It was always only about partisan politics.

Meanwhile, read about the whole Dhallagate saga here!

Rob Anders Throws Boob Bait To Bubbas

...sets out to inflame anti-Muslim sentiment in Calgary:

"It is now illegal to hold opinions that offend radical Muslim activists," and "under section 13 of the so-called 'Human Rights' code, Canadians have been prosecuted for holding personal beliefs which offend radical Muslim Imams and liberal activists."

Meanwhile law Times says appeal the Hadjis Decision. They also conclude that it is the s.54 penalty provisions, not s.13 itself, that may prove unconstitutional:

Hadjis’ conclusions about the constitutionality of s. 13(1) centres on the punitive aspects of the law. Noting the Supreme Court of Canada already dealt with the issue in 1990, he argued that what has changed since then is the imposition of a fine and the expansion of the hate-speech provisions to the Internet during revisions to the Human Rights Act in 2001.

It is that aspect that Hadjis determined to be problematic given the earlier Supreme Court decision’s focus on a conciliatory, rather than penal, approach in dealing with restrictions on free speech under the act.

...and Speechys, who once touted the "real" court system in contrast to the "kangaroo courts" of the HRTs, now want to short circuit the process. They're demanding that Minister of Justice Rob Nicholson squelch any attempt at said appeal.

It Takes A Long Time To Eat A Cow

And you have to break it down into tiny steps. This would be a good 1st step.

Tuesday, September 08, 2009

Steve V. Channels Tommorow's Nanos Poll

All the good shit here.

Stockwell Day: Don't Ask ME About HST

There was another item that came up, unsolicited, at a number of doors -Harmonized Sales Tax, the HST. Some people I talked to understood that the decision to bring in a harmonized tax in BC is a provincial one. For others there was some confusion. So please allow me to clarify this.

The decision to bring in a harmonized tax in BC is a provincial one. Several provinces have moved to an HST. There is a process that was put in place several years ago by the federal Liberals to assist provinces which opt to move in that direction. We have made that same transition process and resources available to the BC government, at their request.

Moving to an HST is the decision of the province of BC. For details on what it means to you please feel free to call your local MLA.


I guess the question I asked earlier this morning--How can any of the other provincial leaders contemplating such a move not wonder if they will be simply hung out to dry [by the Feds] when the going gets a little tough politically? --has been answered: they can't.

Ghosts Of Coalition Past


A good "back pocket" thing for when you run into Conservatives that insist on bringing up the "C" word.

h/t some anonymous dude.

Why Are Federal Tory Candidates Campaigning Against The Harmonized Sales Tax?

If you scroll through the members list of the "We don't want HST" facebook page, you find...a gentleman named Kyle Seeback. Click on Kyle's entry and it takes you to
...here:
Now, if you're wondering why the pols on Kyle's friend list are a bit Tory-heavy, its because Mr. Seeback ran as Tory candidate in Brampton West back in '08, and indeed will be running again for them next time around.
So, another Tory abandoning the Harmonized Sales Tax.
So here is my question: what is the federal Tory position on the HST? The plan is a 2008 budget initiative of the federal government, Finance Minister Jim Flaherty seems to be behind it (depending on the day), but on the other hand we have back-benchers and candidates fleeing in all directions and even the Prime Minister's spokesman seems to want to fob the whole thing off on those provinces that have entered into a harmonization deal with the Feds . How can any of the other provincial leaders contemplating such a move not wonder if they will be simply hung out to dry when the going gets a little tough politically?

Monday, September 07, 2009

Labor Day

Looks like I'll be marching in the big Labor Day parade this morning, and then at the CNE this afternoon, so this may be all you hear from me. Have a good holiday.

Sunday, September 06, 2009

But Bland Works

This line of criticism re the Libs' English ad is as predictable as it is mis-guided. You don't want to introduce your leader to the public with an attack on the other guys. In the words of Jack Stanton, you never want to be the first one to act like an asshole. And when Nicholls writes

Well strategically speaking they make no sense. These kind of positive, hokey ads only work if your guy is way out in front.

...he misses the point entirely. They also work if you want to give the audience the impression that your guy is out in front, at least figuratively--that he's responsible, has a positive vision for the nation, and isn't interested in partisan cheap shots. You don't want to give the impression that he's a perpetually angry jerk with no class and no couth, if only because the Torys have that demographic sewn up already.

I'm sure the Libs have a darker line of campaign rhetoric at the ready, but this is not the time for it. Nicholls problem, and the problem with Conservatives generally, is that for them, if you're not accusing someone of being a pedophile or a commie, its just not campaigning.

New Ads

Here's the English one:



For a second I thought it was being filmed against a backdrop, but you can actually see the milkweed(?) in the background blow in the wind. Not bad: Iggy against a arch-typical Canadian backdrop, a quick out-reach to two of our larger ethnic groups. Positive but not too saccharine, and a quick shot of his fangs at the end to show he's a serious dude.

But I am more an old testament (kill 'em all and put their village to the torch) kind of guy, so I like the French environmental ad better even though my French is crap:


The background is dark as Iggy outlines the Conservatives perfidy, and begins to lighten as he moves onto the Liberal solution. Simple symbolism, but effective. On the whole slightly negative, but not crude or thuggish.

The "deficit" ad is very like this one.

Journalist Asks: Will Ontario Liberal Troubles Harm Federal Liberal Election Hopes?

Answers: probably not.

Saturday, September 05, 2009

Tory Election Strategy: Screw The Rest, We'll Take The West

Ottawa is eyeing a climate change plan that would allow Alberta's oil sands to continue growing – and polluting – but would clamp down on industries in the rest of the country, multiple sources have told the Toronto Star.

Yeah that'll work. On a related note, looks like Bourque is off the Tory pay-roll.

Avid Pianist: The "What Is That Hideous Noise?" Edition

"I've never felt compelled to liken the sound of a piano to bagpipes before," confessed one shocked observer, who requested anonymity to avoid the Prime Minister's unique brand of bloody retribution. "It is as though the instrument's inherent musicality had been drained...no...manually beaten from it."

""Gimme Shelter"? Gimme a break, or better yet: earplugs!" said another appalled music fan. "I'd rather hear gunshots coming from my kid's bedroom!"

Running From The Harper Sales Tax

Ontario Finance Minister Dwight Duncan:

Federal Conservative DNA is all over the HST and denials of any role in its parentage ring hollow, Ontario Finance Minister Dwight Duncan said yesterday.

"I'd refer to Mr. Flaherty's budget and I'd ask those Conservatives why they would vote for that and then speak against it," Duncan said, in the wake of several Conservative MPs and one of the prime minister's spokesman trying to distance the party from the plan to combine the provincial and federal retail sales taxes.

The Iggman himself:

He said the government has pushed the HST across the country during a recession and then has distanced itself when opposition to the tax heats up.

"And we think that's dishonest. They're fully implicated in this decision and they should take responsibility for it."

Ignatieff said Stephen Harper is pretending it's a provincial matter for both British Columbia and Ontario, yet the federal government will be the collector of the tax.

Mind you, as I've written previously, I think the NDP is best set to exploit this issue both provincially and federally, so this isn't a surprise:

Vancouver New Democrat MP Libby Davies scoffs at both the federal Liberals and Conservatives, pointing out that the parties voted for the HST cash enticements in the federal budget.

"It sounds like they're all running for cover and trying to blame each other."

Nor is this:

The New Democrats are framing the upcoming St. Paul's by-election as the chance to send Premier Dalton McGuinty's Liberals a message about the controversial harmonized sales tax.

As the NDP selected lawyer Julian Heller last night as their candidate for the Sept. 17 contest, party leader Andrea Horwath said voters in the midtown Toronto riding can let McGuinty know what they think about the 13 per cent tax.

Just as an aside, the HST issue as it has been playing out in B.C. has brought this guy outta the wood-work. I saw his face and flashed back to that day in the late 70s when I found those little mushrooms in that field behind Belmont Sr. High, near Langford B.C.

Too weird, man. I'm hearing Grateful Dead music playing in my mind.

Friday, September 04, 2009

The Party Line In Its Purest Form

From Tory Whip Jay Hill: Power Hungry Iggy Threatens Economic Instability.

Lemire Case: The Upshot

Section 13 will not go away, and soon will revert to the form found constitutional in the Taylor case.

...which means minus the section 54 of the Canadian Human Rights Act (should this be found to be unconsitutional on appeal).

Even while we're waiting for an appeal of the Hadjis decision, I suspect any new s13 cases will go forward without an attempt at extracting S54 penalties from the respondent, and with greater attempts at "mediation" from the staff of the various HRCs. After all, the point is or should be that the offending material is removed from circulation. And, even without the S54 penalties, once a cease and desist order has been issued by a tribunal, ignoring that order can lead to a finding of "contempt" and, in some cases, jail time.

The s54 penalties are, from the POV of the law's purpose--ie. expunging hateful material--something of a frill. The law would seem to function without them.

Update: Pearl Eliadis agrees.

Twitch In The Numbers Or Liberal Momentum?

I dunno. Angus Reid claims that this is the 1st poll conducted after Iggy's Sept. 1 display of political manhood. While most Canadians are opposed (or strongly opposed) to bringing down the ruling Tories , 42% also think its time for a change of goverment (and hey! the Libs are up 2 points). So any "backlash" to such a move seems likely to be confined to the Op-Ed pages of CanWest newspapers.
Details here.

Thursday, September 03, 2009

Stephen Harper's Greatest Hits



Does he hate Canada?

My favorite bit is a nice little quote towards the end about Human Rights being totalitarian, which puts me in mind of Brian Lilley's post today in which he argues that the Lemire Vs. Warman decision from yesterday will become "election fodder". Gawd I hope so. During the Ontario PC leadership race, polls told us what an anti-human rights stance would likely bring.

Short answer: Doom baby, Doom!

Maxime Bernier Strikes Back

From his blog today, a presser:

Saint-Georges-de-Beauce, September 3, 2009 - The daily paper Le Devoir published a tendentious and sensationalist report this morning about the nature of the documents left by former Foreign Affairs minister Maxime Bernier in a private residence more than a year ago.

Gawd she's hot. That is all.

You Figure It Out: Royal Society On Geo-Engineering

A phase space diagram plotting cost vs. effectiveness of the various methods of geo-engineering under consideration as means of averting AGW. From the Royal Society's report on the topic. Note that "air capture" (ie carbon capture from ambient air), Pielke Jr.'s hobbyhorse, works OK but costs alot, and of course Roger Jr. is not happy with that assessment. Further, he seems to suspect a plot against him and his ideas.
Note too that the cheapest and most effective scheme, pumping aerosols into the stratosphere, is a political no-go. Aerosols shot into the sky in one place come down as acid rain in another country. Oopsie.
PS. The title comes from the fact that the reporters covering this story apparently found the diagram above quite confusing.

As Don Martin

...speaks, so too is Don Martin refuted:

Asked which party they would vote for were a federal election held tomorrow, 32.6 per cent of respondents said they would cast their ballots for Stephen Harper's Tories, while the same percentage opted for Michael Ignatieff's Liberals, EKOS said.

[...]

The Liberals have erased a small but persistent lead enjoyed by the Tories throughout most of the summer by improving their fortunes in the battleground province of Ontario, EKOS said.

Maybe Mr. Martin is waiting on one of those "special" Ipsos polls exclusive to CanWest media.

Wednesday, September 02, 2009

CJC On Lemire Case: Wrong In Law

"The Supreme Court of Canada clearly ruled that s. 13 was constitutional long before the penalty provisions were added to it. As such, Mr. Hadjis should have simply ignored the penalty provisions and applied the appropriate cease and desist order against Mr. Lemire," [Joel Richler, CJC National Honourary Legal Counsel] added.

"This action is known as the doctrine of 'reading out' - a well-established practice endorsed by the Supreme Court of Canada under which the portion of a law that may be unconstitutional is edited out but the remaining constitutional elements are applied. Mr. Hadjis should have 'read out' of section 13(1) the penalty provisions and preserved the rest of the section. Mr. Hadjis failed to consider this option, even though the Supreme Court of Canada has been clear that section 13(1) is perfectly constitutional," Richler explained.

"This was a decision by a single member of the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal. We should recall that there have been two previous decisions by the Tribunal that rejected the constitutional challenges to s. 13. In order to clarify the law, we strongly urge the Canadian Human Rights Commission and Mr. Warman to appeal this decision," CJC CEO Bernie Farber said.

Read the rest through the link.

Lemire Ruling: Section 13 Constitutional

The CHRT decision Warman vs. Lemire came down this morning. Don't have much time to write about it today, but a quick response/fake lawyer opinion:

1) S.13(1) itself is safe, ie. constitutional as per the Taylor decision.

2) The various penalty provisions outlined in S.54(1), which I believe were added to the act later on (1998?), taken in conjunction with 13(1), infringed Lemire's rights under 2(b) of the Charter. Commissioner Hadjis felt that the fact that the CHRC pursued Lemire after he had "amended" his behavior and pulled down the offending material was not in accordance with the "conciliatory" nature of the Canadian Human Rights Act. Short term result: Lemire was guilty of breaching S.13 but no remedial order will be issued against him.

3) Don't know how this will affect Abrams vs. Topham and The Radical Press or future S.13 cases. If I were to guess, I would say that in future the CHRC might have to drop cases where the hate messages which inspired the complaint have been removed by their author/publisher. It won't have any effect on the various Warman vs. whoever lawsuits going forward.

Will add more to this when I am able.

Note To Green Party Supporters

...as your party self-immolates, please consider supporting Michael Ignatieff in the upcoming Federal election. It is an unpalatable truth that the Alberta tar sands cannot simply be shut down or wished away, only managed in a fashion more responsible than is currently the case. And, as the NDP proved in the last Federal and B.C. Provincial elections, they are too beholden to their Union base to push for the kinds of measures necessary to green our automobile, lumber and etc. industries.

And as for Mr. Hertzog, who writes

In attempting to be just like all the other parties in the belief that this will get a single Green MP elected, the Green Party of Canada has thrown out its principles in its bid for power.

...well, principles are lovely in the abstract but under the circumstances this is nothing more than the expression of a political death wish. Without Elizabeth May the federal Green Party is nothing, and if the federal Green Party itself is a factor in her failing to gain a seat in the HOC next election, then the Green Party will lose Elizabeth May. You people will be back to raising money by holding salmon bakes and selling mushrooms, less a political party than a cult of aging hippies running around the gulf islands in Jesus robes and eating roots and berries. D'you want that?

PS. I think she should have run here, by the way. I could see May easily adding another 10% to Nagy's total.

Meanwhile, Out In Alberta


From the campaign of Mark Dyrholm, who is running for leader of Alberta's Wildrose Alliance Party, which has drawn the support of the the separatist Western Business and Taxpayers Association (WBTA) and other Alberta luminaries.

Tuesday, September 01, 2009

Mulclair Resurrects Purple Coalition

Jack and Steve 's Campaign Sweaters
From the Canadian Press:

...MP Thomas Mulcair immediately offered a most girly form of surrender.

"What I'm saying is: the last thing Canadians want is a fourth general election in five years especially as we in the NDP would get slaughtered and we'd better have a bloody good reason for forcing a fourth general election in five years because we would get slaughtered.

"So if Mr. Harper goes about being provocative as he has been in the past, going after key things that Canadians hold dearly like women's rights and the environment, then we'll surrender most girly like because he'll have provoked it.

"If, on the other hand, Stephen Harper comes into Parliament and abuses our asses, then we're going to take it on a case-by-case basis and eventually our caucus will offer its most girly form of surrender."

Some people say when you mix NDP orange and Tory blue you get a purply pink. I say its a pinky purple. But whatever.

What The Hell Does It Mean?

Michael Ignatieff has decided his Liberals will no longer support the Harper government, sources say.

But that doesn't mean he'll move quickly to bring the minority Conservatives down either.

Not that I doubt...no,no, I do not doubt. Iggy knows all, sees all. His gloriousness is both transplendant and transfinite, and though I wish only clarity and yet see no clarity in this statement, it is surely a problem with myself and not the party. I am truly weak, and only another $50 donation to the party will make me strong again.

Yes, yes. Strength and certainty. I need to look at that picture of Iggy shaking his fist again.

There, I am better now.

Update: Clarity?

Sources have told CTV News that the Liberals will put forward a non-confidence motion to force an election this fall -- although they need the support of the NDP and the Bloc Quebecois for that to happen

Further Clarity! Click through to the Globe story above and the line about "not moving quickly" has disappeared.

Hottest August Ever?

Maybe not quite but, according to the UAH website, among the hottest on record and much hotter than last year even though, if you are going by sunspot numbers, the Sun has been dead as a doornail.

According to AGW deniers though, it isn't supposed to be that way.

Stockwell Day On Senate Reform: Reforming The Upper Chamber One Hack At A Time

In his most recent weekly column, the Minister of International Trade Stockwell Day chimes in on the topic of Senate reform, and in particular Prime Minister Harper's latest round of appointments. Here are some column highlights, followed by my own brief remarks:

Then there's the little (big) matter of being unelected. The Prime Minister has invited Premiers to come up with a way of getting their own citizens to elect the person of their choice within their own province. Then the Prime Minister will promise to put them in the Senate.

However, the suggested mechanisms by which a province would put forward its choice for a vacant Senate seat are joke-worthy at best. In all of proposals put forward by the Harper Tories, for example, winning a senate election would not necessarily result in assuming a senate seat. Their first crack at reform took place back at the end of 2006. At that time, The Ottawa Citizen reported:

... the [Conservative] bill proposes to establish a procedure where Elections Canada, which has the legal authority to conduct a federal referendum as well as federal elections, would conduct a form of plebiscite, likely only within provinces that have Senate vacancies.

The results would be presented as information to a prime minister to consider when filling a vacancy.

The consultation could not be legally binding on Harper or subsequent prime ministers because the Constitution stipulates only the Queen, on the advice of cabinet, can name people to the Senate. Unlike all other government appointments, where the Governor General's approval is enough, Senate appointments continue to receive direct approval from the Queen.

Even in the case of Bert Brown, who Albertans chose as their upper chamber representative in 2007, the actual appointment was, in the end, a result of a Prime Ministerial whim:

So far only Alberta has responded by coming up with their own Senate election. They allow for the names of Senate candidates to be added to the ballots during their municipal elections. The province picks up the administration costs and the people decide who their Senator will be.

The last time they did this the winner was Bert Brown. The Prime Minister kept his word and appointed him to the Senate. He sits today in that Chamber, quite proud to be the only elected Senator in that place of over 100 appointees.

Had the Prime Minister chosen to break his word, something he has been occasionally occasionally to do, the people of Alberta would have come up with bupkis.

This problem is exacerbated by the fact that there is no mechanizsm to determine who can offer themselves as a Senate candidate. So, with most reform proposals under consideration, I could put myself forward. And if I won, the Prime Minister could ignore the result. A good outcome, I suppose, but achieved only via an absurd process.

Mr. Day also considers the PM's most recent attempts at reform:

To deal with the problem of it being a life-long position the Prime Minister takes an innovative approach. Whomever the Prime Minister appoints must vow to step down after 8 years, no exceptions, no excuses. So each person he recently appointed, along with the ones he appointed earlier, will be done in 8 years. That's a major change.

No, it is a reform technique that is only as good as the vows of the appointees. Not to be too cynical, but the odds of a Conservative government still being in power federally in 8 years is low, the odds of Stephen Harper heading up that government are infinitesimal. And, either way, if any of his Senate appointees wish to remain in the upper chamber past that date, there is not a thing he or anyone else can do about it.

Mr. Day concludes

One more thing about the latest round of Senate appointees, each one has agreed to work hard from inside the Senate to push for reform. That means when the next federal election is called we may see senators stepping down from the Red Chamber and running for office.

That's progress.

Yeah, or we may not see anything like that, in which case we have the status quo passed off as progress.

Monday, August 31, 2009

Cash Overboard!

I'm sure this didn't come out quite the way Barrie MP Patrick Brown wanted it to.

Out The Conservatives Day Swiftly Approaches

Connie and Co. at Free Dominion, after having been disappointed time after time by the Harper government re free speech issues, finally blew a gasket over the Investigative Powers for the 21st Century (IP21C) Act--which would force ISPs to disclose subscriber information such as name and address, and grant the police broad new powers to obtain transmission data and force ISPs to preserve data--and decided to strike back. Back in July, Connie wrote:

My proposal is that, if this government insists on doing this[IP21C], we strip them of their anonymity, too.

Every blogger and forum owner in Canada should begin compiling a list of usernames that have been used by IP addresses owned by the Conservative Party of Canada or the House of Commons, and we should set a day for a collective "reveal".

Well, I haven't followed the latest on IP21C, but it looks like the gang at FreeD is still...displeased...and it looks like a tentative reveal date has been set:

The 14th of September is nearing.....the day the house resumes sitting and the action begins...

...says ToryCanuck, one of their stalwarts.

Interesting to see what they can pull from their hats. Connie admits that Tory operatives have been pushing propoganda out through the message board for years. If they really can link pseuds to meat world interfaces, who knows what may follow?

Sunday, August 30, 2009

Ryan Doyle Replaces Dumped Michael Coren On CFRB

From Tarek Fatah's Facebook page:

Tarek Fatah survived the storm at CFRB and will continue to co-host the 3-4PM hour with Ryan Doyle. Stay tuned.

Ryan who? And is he more or less fucked up in the head than Michael Coren?

Olivia Chow Threatened

...for handing out fliers at a Toronto town hall copyright forum. The forum, part of the federal government's consultation process as it prepares new copyright legislation, was meant to facilitate discussion of issues surrounding this legislation from the various stake-holders. The fliers contained an interview with NDP MP Charlie Angus in which he called for "balanced" copyright legislation, but when Ms. Chow attempted to distribute this material, private security personnel hired by the event organizers--who appear to have been entertainment industry shills-- told her to lay off or be removed from the hotel at which the consultation was being held.

Members of the Canadian Federation of Students were also set upon for distributing similar material. Their news release re the incident can be found here.

This Is One Anonymous Liberal Source I Can Get Behind

“Even if the Liberals haven't made up their minds about wanting an election, [it's] good to see they have their act together this early.”

I don't think the party ever really got its act together under Dion. At least Ignatieff has the Liberal machine turning over smoothly. Its a start.

Saturday, August 29, 2009

Into The Senate And Off The Hook

Has anyone else is the anglo media or blogosphere picked up on Buzzetti's point? That Doug Finley's newfound parliamentary immunity will allow him to avoid testifying re. the Cons electoral fraud?

From here. Translation of Buzzetti below:

" As for the nomination of Mr. Finley to the Senate, it will have another consequence. Being from now on a member of Parliament, one will not be able to require of him qu' any more; he appears before a committee of the House of Commons for qu' he explains his role in the strategy of electoral financing of the Conservative party in 2006. Mr. Finley is famous being the brain of the mechanism known as of “in and out”, stratagem by which the conservatives are suspected of having spent 1 million dollars moreover than the allowed electoral limit. This cause is always in front of the courts, but the deputies in Ottawa tried l' summer last to hold of the audiences on this subject and any preserving apparatchik n' condescended to present itself, in spite of the assignments to appear been useful in certain cases. Mr. Finley, slinger, s' was presented two days before the date envisaged by requiring d' to be heard immediately, without what it would not return. He had been escorted by the security service. "

Not sure if that helps or not.

Total Confusion In Alberta...

...over bill 44, an update to the province's human rights legislation. A minister-on-minister dust up seems to have occurred between Education Minister Dave Hancock and Culture Minister Lindsay Blackett.

Background: teachers are still worried they might be taken to the Alberta Human Rights Commision for, among other things, discussing sexuality in class without having informed parents in advance, so that said parents might decide whether or not their children are allowed to participate in the discussion or even attend.

Education minister Hancock asked that implementation of this "parental opt-out" clause be delayed until next year and...what?

This story from five hours ago suggests that Blackett has agreed to the delay. This one, from a bit earlier in the day, suggests he still wants to press ahead. So I don't know what the heck is going on, but its sure no way to run a rail-road, let alone a province aspiring to national leadership.

I will make a prediction though: I predict that the opt-out clause eventually comes out of the legislation entirely, and we are left with a document that explicitly disallows discrimination on the basis of sexuality.

Update: Blackett tweets:

Section 9 will take effect on Sept 1, 2010 so formalized process can be created by School Boards.

Avid Pianist, Part II: Stephen's Senate Stuffing Song



“When I play the piano, I become very involved emotionally, I'm no longer the same person. It's not just a hobby,” Mr. Harper said.

Friday, August 28, 2009

Is There Anything That Can Shut Joe Biden Up?

I'm serious. He's eulogizing Kennedy and I've been listening to him for 20 minutes and he's told his life story up to 1967.

Its A Pan!

Catholic Insight's Fr. Alphonse de Valk won't be voting for PCPO candidate Sue-Ann Levy, no matter what her qualifications:

I do not want to be represented by someone who tramples on my beliefs with both her feet, no matter how competent she may be. Yes, I do read her columns and find them well-written and factual. But her personal lifestyle is a slap in my face.

Probably not enough So-Cons in St. Paul to make a difference.

All Hail The New King


...of patronage appointments.

Although I must admit to being a fan of Jacque Demers. If you're old enough to remember what he accomplished with all those crap 80's teams in the Snorris division, you would be too. They said he was doing it "with mirrors" (little pun on his name there).

Here's our boy in action from the 1987-88 season. I'm betting he could kick Mike Duffy's ass anytime.


Note the guy on audio. Don Cherry has always been a huge fan

CFRB Sacks Michael Coren

Free market, I love you.

Here's the BCLSB version of Coren's greatest hits. Here's my favorite, where Coren tells a health science instructor they shouldn't teach because English isn't their 1st language.

Bye Bye asshole.

Thursday, August 27, 2009

Communicate THIS!

Bon Mots from John Williamson, the PM's new director of communications:

On Michelle Muntean, the PM's in-house pyschic:

The idea that these expenses are going to be run up on the public tab and then answers aren't going to be forthcoming about how much its costing is unacceptable from a taxpayers point of view.

On The Harper Torys spending habits:

The lazy, hazy days of summer are here and Conservative MPs are crisscrossing the country and showering it with money. According to news stories, the federal government has announced some $3-billion in spending priorities since Parliament recessed for the summer less than a month ago. That is roughly $100-million a day or more than $4-million every hour. Weren’t the Conservatives elected to root-out waste in government and spend tax dollars judiciously?

[...]

Unhappily, there is nowhere for voters to turn for reform.

And some more:

The Conservatives' program of massive deficit spending is bad news for taxpayers because it will mean paying more interest to service the national debt.

Licking the 3rd rail of Candian politics:

John Williamson, executive director of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, told The Interim it is “obscene that having an abortion at 20 weeks triggered maternity benefits. No birth, no benefits.”

He said it was a “perversion of the EI system,” explaining that employment insurance was designed to “provide benefits to people who, through no fault of their own, find themselves out of work.”

Trashing Quebec Delis:

John Williamson, the federal director of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, thinks the loan is another example of corporate welfare and Conservative vote buying. “There is only one way to describe a zero-interest government loan to business and that is corporate welfare. And with a possible fall election, I think it is safe to also call this vote buying in la belle province," said Williamson.

On last year's election:

Williamson says the spending binge is exactly the kind of pre-election splurge Prime Minister Stephen Harper criticized the Liberals for in the run-up to the 2006 federal election.

On PM Stephen Harper:

And Happy New Year to you Prime Minister, but I hope it’s not as dark as you anticipate. With Maclean’s and with other reporters in year-end interviews, Stephen Harper warned Canadians of tough economic times ahead. To make matters worse, he says the federal government will introduce tough policies to reduce carbon emissions and the public will most likely gripe about it. On taxes, Canadians, it seems, can get stuffed. If the economy slows there will be no relief for taxpayers. What kind of message is this?

On Jim Flaherty:

For the record, I think Mr. Flaherty will keep his job. But he sure is making a mess of the nation's tax code.

Even more on (Tory) government spending:

After the March 19th federal budget, I am becoming a convert to PR. On spending and taxation, the New Government™ is increasingly indistinguishable from the old government.

And on Chrétien vs. Harper:

Another favourite Conservative talking point is that Canadians are getting more value for their tax dollars because Ottawa is better managed today — taxpayers therefore shouldn’t fret over a few billion dollars in spending. But there is little evidence of this improved management. In fact, it is no contest between the Harper government’s spending and that of Mr. Chrétien’s government; the Grits exercised greater fiscal discipline.

Thanks to Ted for this last one.

Latest Ekos Poll

proves previous Ipsos poll crap.

An Ekos poll showed the Conservatives at 32.6 percent of decided voters and the Liberals at 30.9 percent, roughly the same as a week earlier. The two parties tied at 37 percent in Ontario, Canada's most populous province.

"This weeks's national sample of vote intention...suggests they (the Liberals) may want to think twice," Ekos said on Thursday in releasing the results.

But why? Given the efficiency of the Lib. vote etc. etc., these numbers look like a thin Lib. Minority. And, at the very least, the Ont. figure would be a marked improvement over 2008.

Go for it, sez I!

More details at Ms. O'Malley 's.

He Feels His Idealism Slipping Away

If the Liberals got into power again before Senate reform was possible, would the Conservative Senators in office give up their seat simply because their self-imposed eight-year limit was up? Not a snowballs chance in Tahiti. There is no way they would leave their seat to be snatched up again by the Liberals.

So where would that leave us? Well, nowhere really. Except we’d have a whole lot more unelected, unaccountable Conservative Senators...

Let me intensify your despair, Raphy. Deep down, Harper likes the Senate just as it is. He gets to pass silly "tough on crime" measures, blame the Liberals when they go nowhere in the upper house, and reintroduce them later. The same chunk of red meat gets thrown to the bubbas again and again, see? Assuming the current government sticks around long-enough to attain a Senate majority, watch all these symbolic gifts to the base mysteriously disappear. Because Harper would have to actually think about the consequences of his legislation.

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

Mulroney Says Torys Should Bury Hatchet, But Not In His Head

Musings on The Chin's upcoming wing-ding.

Who's coming, who isn't. Maxime Bernier's going to be there. He's bringing his father along as chaperone. So I guess he's available.

This bit is esp. interesting:

A cabinet minister in Mulroney's government, Charest's decision to co-host the event has some speculating he might seek a return to federal politics, perhaps as Harper's eventual replacement.

If true, we might almost be getting to the point where I could vote Tory on the federal level again.

(I remember hearing his shift to Que. provincial politics being analysed 10 years ago as follows: "Well he must know he'll never be PM")

POLiWiTTER

Twitter feeds from all the heavies in one place.

Mucking around there finds some interesting stuff. For example, Sue Ann Levy has a twitter feed a website, is against the planned Scarborough wind-project, and has been endorsed by John Laforet.

Tory MP Colin Carrie seems obsessed with bringing KISS to Oshawa.

Jack Layton's page contains this uplifting message from Rev. Dang:

And so on. There is even an English/French, French/English translation function.

Update: Scott Tribe notes in the comments that tweetcommons offers a very similar service.

Jack Layton And The Purple Coalition: His Mouth Says No No No, His Tie Says Yes Yes Yes

Look at his body language; he looks sad, pensive, as though he has lost or discarded something that was once precious to him, but which now seems a pointless indulgence.

More importantly, look at his neck ware, the most expressive item of clothing on any politician and the one he is most likely to use to send coded signals to The Faithful.

Note the diagonal stripes--they're purple, what you got by mixing NDP orange with Tory blue. These are the colours of the Purple Coalition--the undemocratic NDP/CPoC Alliance that I wrote about yesterday.

Note the black stripes underneath. These represent the death of the young idealist Jack Layton used to be.

And the Message?

Fuck this principled Socialist BULLSHIT! Jack needs an office with a window. Jack is tired of hearing toilets flush next door when's he on the phone schmoozing with Castro. Jack has been squatting in this little crap-hole town nearly 10 years and he's fed up of being last in line to shake the Pope's hand when The Pope comes to town, tired of hearing "Whose the weird little guy with the gay mustache?" because The Pope thinks a union-based pol won't understand Latin. He's tired of the press laughing at him behind his back, and that Green Party chick eyeing his official third party leader stuff and looking so damned impressed. Little does she know!! The games unit is from 20 years ago and all it plays is pac-man! The TV hasn't work in forever; Jack had his staff tape that picture of Obama over the screen! That's why his lips never move! No! No! Jack deserves better. Jack deserves perqs! And Jack is going to get perqs if he has to dance with the Devil himself!

Seriously, forget stories like this. The man is ready to deal. I know neckties.

Some Days You Can't Even Pay Them To Deny

Back in June, I wrote about how Tom Harris of the ICSC (International Climate Science Coalition), an AGW denial group built and, most likely, funded by Australian business man Alan Gibbs (who also makes Humvees), was looking for an Executive Director for the CSCA (Climate Science Coalition of America ), its U.S. affiliate. Among other things, this position required

Exceptional English language oral (including public speaking), writing and editing skills, with a special focus on communicating with laypeople.

...and had a starting salary of $70,000 to $90,000 USD per annum.

Well, its late August now and the CSCA is up and running. But as an interesting side-note, its contact person is...Tom Harris! So they still haven't found a body to stuff in a suit and lie for them for nearly six figures a year.

That's a sign of something, but I'm not sure what.

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

Mixing NDP Orange And Tory Blue

...gives you the purple coalition, coming to an HOC near you.


See what Jack and Steve will be wearing this fall!!

Ipsos Poll Inspired Universal Mistrust

But there was deep skepticism around the poll. Even Harper Tories questioned it, sending out “talking points” to their MPs, noting the poll is not consistent with other polling. A Canadian Press Harris-Decima poll released yesterday afternoon put the two parties in a statistical tie, where they have been all summer.

The release date of this ill-fated survey was supposed to be Monday. In fact though it appeared Sunday evening, ignominiously, on the National Post/Canwest website. Kudos to Don Martin for stepping on the story in his Friday column and thus ruining Canwest's scoop. And kudos to everyone who wrote about it over the weekend. I think this probably did force Canwest's hand towards a Sunday reveal and helped to lessen the story's impact yesterday morning.

Making Moves, Sending Signals

John Baird and Dalton's McGuinty's musings re a pedestrian tunnel to the island airport doesn't count for much as a discussion of real policy. Its all pretty blue sky stuff that may or may not happen somewhere way, way down the road (Adam Vaughan is surely correct that there is no way a tunnel will get built by 2011). But what it does show is McGuinty's willingness to cut Mayor David Miller loose politically. Dalton gave Miller The City Of Toronto Act, and all he got in return were hassles and piles of garbage. Don't expect much more in the way of financial assistance from the province over the next couple of years (and,it goes without saying, the Feds). Mayor Miller will end his 2nd term a very lonely man.

Monday, August 24, 2009

Republicans For Ignatieff Come Out





I know I shouldn't be giving attention to these guys, but I do love a good mystery and, yes, a good "viral campaign" even if its for evil ends. More pictures here. For what its worth, this is all supposed to be happening at the Missouri State Fair, and all the politicians referenced in the handouts above are indeed Missouri Republicans.

Rumour: BMO TU?

Bank Of Montreal Gaming Its Books? Noted advisor to market short-sellers Dan Amoss thinks so.

Amos will name names at 12 noon today. The clue is in Amos' description of the as yet unspecified institution:

“With a 192 year old history and 37,000 employees, its crash would drop like an A-bomb on unsuspecting shareholders…”

BMO was founded in 1817.

PS. This report's been floating around since the 20th and hasn't moved BMO's stock at all. So who knows?

Fun With Karl Popper

Popper's Falisifcationalism:

If T(Theoretical Statement) -> ~O(observational Statement)

Example:

If Solar activity drives climate change -> It is not the case that low solar activity will correlate with high temperatures.

By modus tollens, the observation that:

O
...implies:

~ T

which is to say that our theoretical statment has been falsified/refuted.

For example:

There have been no sunspots for almost 42 days and there are none in the offing and July 2009 was the second hottest July on record.

implies:

Anthony Watts is fucked up in the head.

Q.E.D

Of course, that's the "side of a cracker jack box" version of Karl Popper's Falsificationism. But WUWT is side of "side of a cracker jack box" science.

Sunday, August 23, 2009