Thursday, April 06, 2006

Is Intelligent Design Oozing its Way into Canada?

From the Montral Gazette:

A clash between McGill University and the key federal agency that funds social science research in the country is sparking a scholarly debate in Canada about the theory of evolution.

McGill University says the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council made a "factual error" when it denied Professor Brian Alters a $40,000 grant on the grounds that he'd failed to provide the panel with ample evidence that Charles Darwin's theory of evolution is correct.

Prof denied grant over evolution

The name of the rejected project was "Detrimental Effects of Popularizing Anti-evolution's Intelligent Design Theory on Canadian Students, Teachers, Parents, Administrators and Policymakers."

Okay, reading the article and glancing at the conversation on Slashdot, it is not entirely clear what is going on here. Grant proposals get turned down for alot of reasons, and Professors are not above venting sour grapes. The SSHRC claims that Dr. Alters is taking "one line in the letter out of context".

But it is McGill, not Dr. Alters, that has raised the complaint, and the one line he is supposedly misinterpreting says that Dr. Alter did not provide "adequate justification for the assumption in the proposal that the theory of evolution, and not intelligent design theory, was correct."

Further, Janet Halliwell, the SSHRC's executive vice-president and a chemist by training, remarked on the situation by noting that there are phenomena that "may not be easily explained by current theories of evolution" and that the scientific world's understanding of life "is not static. There's an evolution in the theory of evolution."

I do not find these remarks particularly comforting.

I think several questions need to be asked here. The most important one is: what are the political affiliations of Ms. Halliwell and the other members of the SSHRC committee, who include Susan Bennett of the department of English literature at the University of Calgary; Lawrence Felt of the department of sociology at Memorial University of Newfoundland; University of Ottawa history professor Ruby Heap; Gilbert Larochelle from the department of human sciences at the Universite du Quebec a Chicoutimi; and Ruth Rose from the department of economics at the Universite du Quebec a Montreal. Are they Harper appointees? Are the Conservatives trying to sneak hard right yobos into the education system while maintaining a moderate front?

Now, again, Dr. Alter may well be maliciously misinterpreting a line from a letter informing him that, essentially, his research is unworthy. Given what I know of academia, that would not surprise me and, if so, shame on him. But on the other hand any encroachment of Intelligent Design into the Canadian education has to be fought tooth and nail. I could rant on and on about that, but won't right now.

We shall see where this goes.

Update Friday, 11:42 AM: SaskBoy is also writing about this back at Abandoned Stuff:

http://www.abandonedstuff.com/2006/04/06/unintelligent-deny-luther-and-campion-take-body-blow-ancient-dentist-drill-evidence/

Update Friday, 6:22 PM: Another story in the Globe about this issue. A link gets you to the firewall. Instead, Google "Brian Alters Evolution Globe" and slip on through.

One thing that has become clear to me is that Dr. Alters is well-known and well-established in his field, and not the kind of researcher you would turn down lightly He was one of six expert witnesses called to the stand in the recent Dover, PA trial, wherein a local school board was taken to court for attempting to teach Intelligent Design as an alternative to evolution, and a short account of his testimony can be found here:

http://www.mcgill.ca/newswire/?ItemID=18027

(Note: one day I will figure out how to work the link function on this fucking system so all my links aren't a mile long, but not today, apparently)

60 comments:

Anonymous said...

Well, you've been trolling all over the Internet making insanely stupid comments and leaving your spam-like canned mega-comment on various blogs linking back to your blog for hours.

Finally you have a comment on yours.

You're an f'in moron.

Anonymous said...

Here, I'll double your comment count.

Take the tinfoil hat off.

Anonymous said...

I'll triple it.

Shut this blog down, fuckwit.

Saskboy said...

Wow you've attracted more trolls than I have in months of pretty active blogging.

Feel free to link to my entry on ID then trackback to it. If you don't know how to trackback I'll explain it.

Saskboy said...

OK, now that you've linked my story, you look in the comments section of it there's a link called Trackback. Copy that link, and find a free trackback pinger on the web, one can be found for googling for Wizbang trackback ping.

Then fill in the information in the form and pres submit and your story information that you enter into the form will appear in my comments section as a trackback. On some blog systems the trackbacks are seperate from the comments, but not on my WordPress.

Look through SkylarKD's blog linked on my blog site, as I explained the trackback process there to her recently, or look up samanthaburns.com for lots of info.

bigcitylib said...

You the man, Saskboy.

Saskboy said...

In Blogger, you write plain text, then highlight it and click the Link button and paste in the URL and it writes the HTML for an A HREF link.

--
Here's what I wrote the other day to explain it to SkylarKD:

I'll post it here so the world can learn.
If you write something that is about another blog entry, you can ofen trackback to it, so that visitors to the original blog also see your site wrote about it.
Using this entry of yours as an example of the steps:
1. Find a Trackback URI on the post you want to have your article's link appear on. It might be in a link called Trackback, and it will be a URL that isn't the permalink URL of the origional blog.
2. Copy that Trackback URI
3. After posting your story with a link to my blog entry included somewhere in the post, go to Wizbang or another trackback pinger [there's one built into Wordpress if you ever move from Blogger], and paste the Trackback URI into the Ping spot.
http://www.aylwardfamily.com/content/tbping.asp
that's the Wizbang site.

4. Paste the URL of your blog entry into the right spot, in the form.
Paste an excerpt too. Submit the Trackback and it will give a status in XML code.

In a few minutes, or whenever I moderate my trackback pings, your link will appear on my blog [in the comment section on Wordpress, but for some blogs right on the main page].

Anonymous said...

[url=http://nudegirlinfo.com] Nude Girl[/url]
[url=http://nudelolitasite.com/index.shtml] Girl[/url]
[url=http://undressedlolita.com] Undressed and oversexed[/url]
[url=http://mirampics.com/index.shtml] pics[/url]
[url=http://mirampics.com/index1.shtml] pics 1[/url]
[url=http://mirampics.com/index2.shtml] pics 2[/url]
[url=http://mirampics.com/index3.shtml] pics 3[/url]
[url=http://mirampics.com/index4.shtml] pics 4[/url]
[url=http://mirampics.com/se/pages/teen/index.shtml] Lolita and teen lolita models[/url]

http://porno-pics.base-pics.com/index.html porno pics
[url=http://porno-pics.base-pics.com/index.html]porno pics[/url]

Anonymous said...

http://dermo-keys.com/index1.shtml
http://dermo-keys.com/index2.shtml
http://dermo-keys.com/index3.shtml
http://dermo-keys.com/index4.shtml
http://dermo-keys.com/index5.shtml
http://dermo-keys.com/index6.shtml
http://dermo-keys.com/index7.shtml
http://dermo-keys.com/index8.shtml
http://dermo-keys.com/index9.shtml
http://dermo-keys.com/index10.shtml
http://dermo-keys.com/index11.shtml
http://dermo-keys.com/index12.shtml
http://dermo-keys.com/index13.shtml
http://dermo-keys.com/index14.shtml
http://dermo-keys.com/index15.shtml

Anonymous said...

http://roorex.net/en History of Education

http://roorex.net/reg-Luxembourg-165.html Luxembourg
Luxembourg

Anonymous said...

http://erotic.artmam.com/ - erotic art

http://fine-art.artmam.com/ - oil painting art

http://sensual.artmam.com/ - erotic drawing


http://artmam.net/Dir-Middle_East.htm Middle East
Middle East

Anonymous said...

Good afternoon many have machines which not insuranced,
you have a unique opportunity only today to receive insurance the machine free of charge
[url= http://auto-insurance.halychen.com/index.html ]auto insurance[/url]
[url= http://auto-insurance.halychen.com/map.html ]auto insurance[/url]
[url= http://cars-insurance.halychen.com/index.html ]cars insurance[/url]
[url= http://cars-insurance.halychen.com/map.html ]cars insurance[/url]
[url= http://texascarinsurance.fromborg.com/map.html ]texas car insurance[/url]
[url= http://texascarinsurance.fromborg.com/index.html ]texas car insurance[/url]
[url= http://carinsurancequotes.halychen.com/map.html ]car insurance quotes[/url]
[url= http://carinsurancequotes.halychen.com/index.html ]car insurance quotes[/url]
[url= http://carinsurancepolicy.halychen.com/map.html ]car insurance policy[/url]
[url= http://carinsurancepolicy.halychen.com/index.html ]car insurance policy[/url]
[url= http://xanaxaxa.blogspot.com ]xanax[/url]
[url= http://phenne.blogspot.com ]phentermine[/url]
[url= http://tramadol400.blogspot.com ]buy tramadol[/url]

Anonymous said...

Hi people
I do not know what to give for Christmas of the to friends, advise something ....

Anonymous said...

Hello. Good day
Who listens to what music?
I Love songs Justin Timberlake and Paris Hilton

Anonymous said...

Mmm my sweety private weblink collection. I hope you enjoy it !
ass parade
naruto xxx





------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
About Christmas
merry christmas

Anonymous said...

Hello!
Advise, where it is better to insure my Alfa Romeo. Has found good offer buy car insurance online MERCEDES. But the prices bite. Help! I want more cheaply!
P.S. [url=http://worldautoinsurance.heiten.info/index.html]buy car insurance online HONDA[/url]

Anonymous said...

business school Pio [url=http://business-school.italy-info.org/index.html]business school Vera[/url]
giochi on line Luca [url=http://giochi-on-line.italy-info.org/index.html]giochi on line Vera[/url]

Anonymous said...

gioco on line Ave [url=http://gioco-on-line.italy-info.org/index.html]gioco on line Ilva[/url]
tattoo design Igor [url=http://tattoo-design.italy-info.org/index.html]tattoo design Lisa[/url]
tattoo and piercing Isa [url=http://tattoo-and-piercing.italy-info.org/index.html]tattoo and piercing Mina[/url]

Anonymous said...

Great work guys. Good stuff. I found lots of intresting things here. I will be back!
- bigcitylib.blogspot.com m
07 car civic honda
buy used car
car undefined used
used car bergen
used car oakland
used car greensboro
used car raleigh
used car killeen
used car vallejo
used car tacoma

Anonymous said...

I present to you this cool site about [url=http://sites.blockstar.com/viagra/]viagra[/url]
and
[url=http://sites.blockstar.com/eviagra/]viagra[/url]
May be its help you to find him...

Anonymous said...

Please , do not delete it . Ineed money.
[url=http://32url.com/?7ug3]tramadol[/url]
[url=http://32url.com/?yuV9]vaniqa[/url]
[url=http://32url.com/?Aws8]estradiol[/url]
[url=http://32url.com/?IKFh]diflucan[/url]
[url=http://32url.com/?vBPE]xanax[/url]
[url=http://32url.com/?RM2V]nexium[/url]
[url=http://32url.com/?e6jX]lipitor[/url]
[url=http://32url.com/?pmgJ]clomid[/url]
[url=http://32url.com/?M4dx]valium[/url]
[url=http://32url.com/?ZYjl]zoloft[/url]
[url=http://32url.com/?WbwM]effexor[/url]
[url=http://32url.com/?5p3Z]ambien[/url]
[url=http://32url.com/?Kh3s]ativan[/url]
[url=http://32url.com/?nhu2]carisoprodol[/url]
[url=http://32url.com/?Lgar]celebrex[/url]

Anonymous said...

Please , do not delete it . Ineed money.












Anonymous said...

Please , do not delete it . Ineed money.
[url=http://antivert.phpbbx.de/]Antivert[/url]
[url=http://cyclobenzaprine.phpbbx.de/]Cyclobenzaprine[/url]
[url=http://flexeril.phpbbx.de/]Flexeril[/url]
[url=http://flextra.phpbbx.de/]Flextra[/url]
[url=http://zanaflex.phpbbx.de/]Zanaflex[/url]
[url=http://butalbital.phpbbx.de/]Butalbital[/url]
[url=http://aldara.phpbbx.de/]Aldara[/url]
[url=http://condylox.phpbbx.de/]Condylox[/url]
[url=http://denavir.phpbbx.de/]Denavir[/url]
[url=http://famvir.phpbbx.de/]Famvir[/url]
[url=http://zovirax.phpbbx.de/]Zovirax[/url]
[url=http://aphthasol.phpbbx.de/]Aphthasol[/url]
[url=http://atarax.phpbbx.de/]Atarax[/url]
[url=http://dovonex.phpbbx.de/]Dovonex[/url]

Anonymous said...

Find in WEB
Xanax
[url=http://111420.homepagemodules.de/]Xanax[/url]
http://111420.homepagemodules.de/
Thanks!

Unknown said...

greetings to all.
I would first like to thank the writers of this blog by sharing information, a few years ago I read a book called Real Estate Investment costa rica in this book deal with questions like this one.

Steve said...

Hello .. firstly I would like to send greetings to all readers. After this, I recognize the content so interesting about this article. For me personally I liked all the information. I would like to know of cases like this more often. In my personal experience I might mention a book called Generic Viagra in this book that I mentioned have very interesting topics, and also you have much to do with the main theme of this article.

Unknown said...

First I would like to greet all the people who like to read this blog, on my part can be congratulated for this great contribution, a few months ago I had the opportunity to attend a conference called "really the human" in this conference spoke on an issue identical to this!

dailyupdate said...

Very interesting blog. Its an informative topic.

ইনস্যুরেন্স 

Chauffeur said...

Car Rental
Car Rental
Car Rental
Car Rental
Car Rental
Car Rental
Car Rental
Car Rental
Car Rental
Car Rental

Chauffeur said...

Thank you so much for great content.

Chauffeur Service
Chauffeur Service
Chauffeur Service
Chauffeur Service
Chauffeur Service
Chauffeur Service
Chauffeur Service
Chauffeur Service
Chauffeur Service
Chauffeur Service

Chauffeur said...

Thank you so much, your article is very helpful.

VIP Chauffeur
VIP Chauffeur
VIP Chauffeur
VIP Chauffeur
VIP Chauffeur
VIP Chauffeur
VIP Chauffeur
VIP Chauffeur
VIP Chauffeur
VIP Chauffeur

VIP Car Rental AE said...

nice blog, thank you.

rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai

VIP Car Rental AE said...

Wonderful, what a blog it is! This blog provides helpful information to us, keep
it up.

rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai

VIP Car Rental AE said...

Excellent information on your blog, thank you for taking the time to share with us.

rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai

VIP Car Rental AE said...

I like the valuable info you supply on your articles.

rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai

VIP Car Rental AE said...

Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I am impressed!


rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai

VIP Car Rental AE said...

great blog, I am impressed!

rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai

VIP Car Rental AE said...

"nice work, It's an interesting topic.


rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai

VIP Car Rental AE said...

I am really enjoying reading your well written articles.

rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai

VIP Car Rental AE said...

Excellent website. Lots of useful info here.

rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai

VIP Car Rental AE said...

"rent Lamborghini Dubai
rent Lamborghini Dubai
"

VIP Car Rental AE said...

thank you for sharing this with us.

rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
undefined

VIP Car Rental AE said...

thank you for sharing this with us, great artical.

rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai

VIP Car Rental AE said...

thank you for sharing , great artical.

rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai

VIP Car Rental AE said...

thank you for sharing, an outstanding article.

rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai
rolls Royce rental Dubai

Wall Street DXB said...

Thanks for the useful facts.

Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai

VIP Car Rental AE said...

This post could not be written any better!

Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai

VIP Car Rental AE said...

amazing artical.

Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai
Porsche Rental Dubai

Chauffeur said...

nice article.

chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai

Chauffeur said...

i like this article.

chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai

Chauffeur said...

great content.


chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai

Chauffeur said...

great content, thank you.


chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai

Chauffeur said...

Thе blog provides useful info to uѕ.


chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai

Chauffeur said...

like.

chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai

Chauffeur said...

I like this info.

chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai

Chauffeur said...

thanks for the useful info.


chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai
chauffeur service dubai

Chauffeur said...

"chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service
luxury chauffeur service Dubai
Dubai chauffeur service rolls Royce
monthly chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur driven car hire Dubai
rolls Royce chauffeur Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service
luxury chauffeur service Dubai
"

Chauffeur said...

very rich article. Happy to read.

chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service
luxury chauffeur service Dubai
Dubai chauffeur service rolls Royce
monthly chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur driven car hire Dubai
rolls Royce chauffeur Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service
luxury chauffeur service Dubai

Chauffeur said...

Great post....Thank you

chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service
luxury chauffeur service Dubai
Dubai chauffeur service rolls Royce
monthly chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur driven car hire Dubai
rolls Royce chauffeur Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
monthly chauffeur service Dubai
luxury chauffeur service Dubai

Chauffeur said...

greetings to all.


chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur service
luxury chauffeur service Dubai
Dubai chauffeur service rolls Royce
monthly chauffeur service Dubai
chauffeur driven car hire Dubai
rolls Royce chauffeur Dubai
chauffeur service Dubai
monthly chauffeur service Dubai
luxury chauffeur service Dubai